fbpx
Menu

Managing criticism calmly

HomeForumsEmotional MasteryManaging criticism calmly

New Reply
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #121724
    believe
    Participant

    I stumbled upon tinybuddha a couple of days back after a spat with my mother. I was dressed to go out. She asked me to change the way I had done my hair when i was ready to step out and I refused. That irked her and brought out the list of issues she has with the way I look, the way I dress and some of my habits/ aspects of my lifestyle.I don’t live with her but she is with me now for a couple of months. My mother is a hardy person with strong ideas about things/ life/ people. She is also anxious has a need to keep giving instructions very few minutes e.g. did u have water… you never drink water or why don’t you wear this, you have the worst choice in clothes.She is growing older and some of these traits are getting worse. While I see that, I am not able to manage my emotions when I am criticised about my weight or about the quality of my hair or when she tells me that there are some clothes I should stop wearing because they are not meant for my body type or when she says I have peanuts for determination and never finish things that I start or when she says that as a woman I should be doing somethings that I dont do. It drives me up the wall. At times she is in a good mood and jokes about it but at that time it is not so bad, but then there are these half mocking moments like ” sigh! look at some people they looks so good whatever they wear” “just because people wear these clothes you needn’t you look squat and stunted”” sigh! we thought she’d grow really tall”” I used to think she’d be a great sportsperson” (this used to irk me in my teenage not anymore i, but just remembered it) ” sigh I wish God had made you a little slimmer” ” Why are you so sensitive, cant you take a joke” For many years i reacted by snapping back that I don’t care and that she has a problem and is too fussy about these things or that she needs to live with it. On bad days quietly walked away and cried alone. Sometimes I’d joke about it on the outside simmering inside. I almost hate her in those moments and feel like my head is about to burst. On a few occasions recently I have told her to back off and that I am not interested in listening to which she has said that she is a mother and it is quite natural that she is very concerned about her childerns well being no matter how grown up they are and this she cannot change about herself. I used to love my exercise time and walks till she came over and then I stopped after a few arguments. Id come back from a walk and she’d ask how many kms I did and when I told her she’d say why didnt you do xyz…. it doesn’t matter. I have been discussing this with my husband on bad days (he is away right now but my pillar of strength and soul mate for several years) and he asked to draw my boundaries and protect myself. Actually from far it may even sound funny that a grown independent woman like me should even be affected by this. but it is constant and difficult to escape. I have gone through my own journey of being full of self doubt, but externally confident to believing in myself and my capabilities and being able to speak my mind and have conviction in what I say. When I look back I think I have done well for myself, but this journey of self development is long and confusing. the moment I find peace and think this is it, in comes my mother and my calmness crumbles like a pack of cards and I am grappling in thin air for all the concepts of mindfulness and catching nothing. I haven’t got a hold on compassion for myself or for others. How to love and protect myself unconditionally in these specific moments ( it is easy in a non threatening environment)? How do I draw boundaries without anger. While I write here I can clearly see that when people criticise that have something to say but I need not take it personally, but this is so difficult to put in action. I think I just stop listening in these moments or I listen and I hear something I just don’t like and try to resist in my head which gives me this explosive feeling. I don’t even know if there is a connection but many years back when I went for a reiki initiation course the master observed that my channels were blocked . I didn’t I understood this then and I don’t practice reiki anymore but somehow there seems to be a connection. all this resistance . I have nothing against my mother to be honest. I only wish she is quiet for most part of the day and we can talk normal about things instead of obsessing over how I look and my exercise. My feelings evaporate the minute she is peaceful and has a few distractions to keep her busy. I am seeking some understanding of myself – why I resist and get angry instead of letting go. Maybe I perceive a huge risk in being vulnerable.why is this so difficult and how can I be free of this.
    Thank you for your patience.

    #121725
    believe
    Participant

    Why do I perceive negative comments/ observations about my physical appearance as threat?
    What should I listen to when someone makes such a observation? I am baffled because I cant put a finger on the persons intent or expectation from me and my mind blocks everything for that minute.
    What should I tell myself?
    How should I respond to the person making the observation?

    #121728
    Inky
    Participant

    Hi kavita,

    Your mom talks that way to you because it is now her default setting for talking to you after decades.

    In short, it is a bad habit.

    What you need to do is break her habit.

    One Easter my mom started in on three of the siblings’ weight. One sib was getting angry. The other ran into the other room crying. When she started in on me, I grabbed a “NO!” button from Staples (any loud noise maker would do) and pressed the button. “NO!”

    She was startled and upset. She started in on my weight again. “NO!” The children were laughing. The joke was on her. Once again, she made a comment (though more obliquely). “NO!”

    Wouldn’t you know it, the habit was broken!

    Now we talk politics. Bring on politics! Yay!!

    Good Luck,

    Inky

    • This reply was modified 7 years, 4 months ago by Inky.
    #121732
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear kavita:

    You asked: ” why I resist and get angry instead of letting go.?” because you are under verbal attack by your mother. It is not natural to let go when you are attacked.

    You asked: “why is this so difficult and how can I be free of this.” It is so difficult because a person can not live peacefully when under attack. When attacked a person suffers and automatically gets scared and/ or angry.

    You wrote: “Maybe I perceive a huge risk in being vulnerable.”- it is a huge risk to make yourself vulnerable to a person who attacks you. As a matter of fact, making yourself vulnerable (by allowing the attacker to attack you) will only hurt you.

    These are your words describing how you suffer and suffered from her verbal attacks: “”It drives me off the wall…irk me….cried alone…simmering inside…feel like my head is about to burst…I stopped (exercise)… explosive feeling”

    You made progress with your confidence and well being away from your mother, but “the moment I find peace and think this is it, in comes my mother and my calmness crumbles”- clearly, she is damaging to your well being.

    Solution: stop the attacks: assert yourself successfully, tell her specifically what of her “comments” (euphemism for attacks) and “observations” are unacceptable and will not be tolerated. And if she persists, tell her the consequence (her leaving your home). If she still persists, follow through with the consequence.

    OR, have her move out, or you move out so the two of you don’t live together. If on the phone, hang up the moment she starts an attack. Have no contact with her if she insists on continuing to attack you.

    Regarding what of her comments and observations you should take seriously and consider? None. She lost my trust in having anything to say that should be considered with a comment like: “I wish God had made you a little slimmer”- because what can YOU possibly do about her Wish and about having been born a certain way.

    anita

    #122123
    Mimi
    Participant

    kavita,

    I like what Inky said, with that “No!” technique. That sounds like a much quicker way to get to the results that I finally got with my nagging and critical mother.

    My mother was much like yours, always criticizing me about everything. I would just bite my tongue (for the first 30 years of my life), but when I would leave her presence, I was so upset. Eventually, I kept cutting her off completely. I would tell her off, usually in a letter, and then not speak to her for months or longer. After about 3 times of this she actually learned to stop nagging at me. I’m sure that at that point she probably still thought everything negative and just didn’t say it, or would say it to others behind my back, but at least that was something I could live with.

    Now, though, years later, she’s actually turned into a loving, caring mother. I don’t know how, but she grew up. Well, mostly. She still picks on other people sometimes, but not me. She knows I won’t put up with it. Her nagging seems to come out when she is anxious. She either can’t face herself or what is going on around her, and she becomes critical of people. She thinks she’s helping them, but only makes them mad. She’s good to me, though.

    The funny thing is, she would criticize me all the time, my whole childhood and part of my adulthood, but most of the time, even now, if you criticize her in any way she almost falls apart. She can dish it out, but not take it – at all. It’s so strange.

    I don’t know if this helps you at all. Well, maybe it just helps to know that someone else experienced a lot of what you have. I must say, though, I don’t believe what some people have said (not here, but elsewhere) – that people don’t change, etc. They can change, if they care enough about having you in their life. It has to come to the point where you say that this is damaging to me, so either stop it or stay away from me. At least, that’s how I had to do it. I think if I hadn’t forced my mom to change, I might not even be alive now, because the stress of her nagging and criticism would’ve killed me.

    Oh, another thing is that now my mom actually sees and understands some of what she’s done in the past and has apologized (I never thought it would happen). She sees it because of her grandson and his bad father. She’s gained some understanding of what I went through because of seeing what her grandson goes through. So, there really is hope. I’m living proof, and so is Inky.

    Mimi

    #122426
    believe
    Participant

    Thank you for your response Mimi, Anita and Inky. I am grateful that you took out time to understand and write back. I took some time to think about this too. After I wrote about this on the forum I actually experienced some guilt for having written in a public forum about someone so close in my life because there is a good chance that my mother will get judged for her behaviour, but I needed an outlet so that is behind me now.
    Anita, thank you you for answering my questions. That helped me accept my emotions and understand that they maybe a natural response to perceived threat.
    Mimi and Inky I am very thankful that you went out and shared your personal experience. What you have shared is invaluable because it gives me hope. I have also tried the stop technique in my own way and only more recently but usually accompanied with a lot of anger. I have seen some change in the last one week with some help from a family member … the exchange is somehow diffused with people around and is on the lighter side. I think ill try this repeatedly for sometime and see how it works… I also realise that repeating the same response reduces the emotion and anger that goes with it, but lets see if it works on bad days.

    #122432
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear kavita:

    It is very, very common for a child, and an adult-child to feel guilty for even thinking negatively about one’s mother, let along verbalizing it or writing about her for others to read. This feeling of guilt does not mean you did wrong sharing here. Children (of any age) feel loyal to their parents, especially to abusive parents.

    Post anytime.

    anita

    #122667
    Mimi
    Participant

    I can certainly relate to that feeling of guilt after talking or complaining about my mother. My husband said once about the guilt, “That’s because she has you well-trained.” He’s right. That’s how she used to be. Always wanting me to be how she wanted me to be, and wanting me to feel bad whenever I wasn’t pleasing her. That’s how you make a little quiet, robotic child who doesn’t bother you too much (but who is a mess on the inside, of course).

    It’s interesting, though, that recently when I talked about my mom on this thread, I didn’t feel that guilt at all. Partly it’s because I wasn’t discussing her anywhere that it could get back to her (like, if I wrote to my sister and it got accidentally forwarded), but also I think it’s because we are in a much healthier place right now with our relationship.

    Kavita, any technique you use that works for you with your mother is a good one. I can tell you from experience that getting that pain to stop is the first step towards feeling so much better. After that, there is still a lot of healing to do, but when you stop the new pain and criticism from piling on top, it’s a lot more manageable.

    Just use some self-talk whenever those guilt feelings come up, and tell yourself that it’s for your health that you have to let these things out and try to put a stop to the new hurts, too.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.