Knowing Which Advice is Right

“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and common sense.” ~Buddha

The old cliché, “I say tomayto, you say tomahto,” has been popping up in my head recently, mainly because of a lesson I recently learned after years of trial and error.

For the last several years, I have been closely listening to and reading the advice of “experts” on subjects related to life, love, business, and the pursuit of happiness. I have come to an astonishing (for me, anyway) conclusion: Everybody is right, and everybody is wrong.

Confused? Allow me to explain with an example.

About 18 months ago, I changed careers from newspaper journalism to insurance sales. When I first started in the insurance industry, my boss told me that to be successful I would have to not let “no” bother me. Just keep trucking, let that rejection roll like water off a duck’s back, he would say.

He also told me persistence was a major key to selling life insurance. Keep calling clients, even if they blow you off a few (or in one case, many) times.

His advice worked with one client. I literally called her a dozen or more times. She bought insurance, and then canceled.

I scheduled a follow-up appointment to find her some more affordable insurance. She canceled. Another follow-up appointment scheduled. Another canceled. This literally went on for three months.

Finally, we were able to get the insurance she was looking for at a price she could afford.

After writing that application, my boss (let’s call him Jay) said, “Let this be a lesson on the power of persistence.”

A few weeks later, my boss’s boss (let’s call him Brent) gave me some very different advice: “Never call a potential client more than five or six times. It makes you look desperate.”

I have learned that, in many cases, this advice is also true. Calling too many times will certainly not work on a lot of clients. But, in the above-mentioned example, it did work.

So, I asked myself, “Whose advice is right, and whose is wrong?”

My answer: Both are right and both are wrong. It really just depends on the circumstance.

Had I followed Brent’s rule, I never would have sold the policy—and thus been late on my rent.

Sometimes, rigidly following someone’s advice is a bad idea, even when that person is adamant their advice will work.

Put simply, I learned that life is not a mathematical equation. In math, two plus two will always equal four. That’s a guarantee.

In life, there are no guarantees—well, except for death and taxes. There are dozens of ways to get from point A to point B, to accomplish a goal, to live your dreams. Or as my father used to tell me, “There is more than one way to skin a cat.” (Please forgive all the clichés!)

You have to decide which route is right for you in any given situation. Are you going to follow Jay’s advice or Brent’s advice, or do you do things in your own, unique way? You are the only person who can make that decision.

For every person who says go east to find happiness, peace, better relationships, financial success, etc. there is another who will tell you to go west—or north or south.

After years of taking people’s advice in spite of my instincts screaming bad idea, I have learned that I need to trust myself, my intuition, gut, and heart, first and foremost. 

This has been a revelation to me and opened up so many more opportunities. And it taught me that, hey, maybe my own ideas deserve some merit. Maybe I do know what will work best and what won’t. After all, nobody knows me better than myself.

I used to be so self-critical that I often made decisions I later regretted, sometimes within seconds.

Now, I realize trial and error is a part of life and the quickest way to get what you want in life is to trust yourself, go for it, and let the chips fall where they may.

Even if I’m wrong or if things don’t turn out like I had hoped, at least now I know I am going in the right direction.

I am following my own instincts, for good or ill. And I am solving the challenges of life my way and at my own pace.

When I follow my own instincts and things don’t work out, I can keep my head held high and know that I gave it my best shot. When I follow someone else’s advice against my own judgment and things don’t turn out, I feel like I am selling myself short. I feel like I am failing because I am ignoring my better judgment—and that can be self-defeating.

Am I saying never follow the advice of others? Of course not. Everybody is an expert at something and ignoring the advice of people who have been more successful in a given field can also be self-defeating. All I am saying is ask yourself: Does this advice sound right for me?

Thankfully, this new revelation has me on a clearer path to self-reliance and self-discovery. Because of this, I have also become more understanding of other people’s points of view.

Whether I agree with them or not, I can still put myself in their shoes while not stepping out of my own so to speak. It’s sort of like saying tomahto.

Try it for yourself. It’s quite liberating.

Photo by Santosh Kumar GM

About Mike Linn

Mike Linn is a former newspaper journalist who currently enjoys employment as a life and health insurance producer. He enjoys hanging out with friends and meeting people who have unique and positive perspectives on life. A Florida native, Linn lives in Little Rock, Ark.

See a typo, an inaccuracy, or something offensive? Please contact us so we can fix it!
  • Well said, Mike! Only we know what is best for us. It’s taking advice with a filter that works best in the long run. Sift out what doesn’t hold true for our soul and being – leaving behind that which will feed our soul and being.

  • I love this! So true. 🙂 

  • Mike Linn

    Thanks guys. Appreciate the feedback.

  • Blissdogcoach

    Great article! Very true!

  • Julie

    Great article, Mike! My current self-improvement “project” is to stop second-guessing myself. You hit the nail on the head.

  • John, a Limey

    Nah! Mike.  I think you’ll find it is: “You say tomayto, I say tomato.” (LOL)

    I found it a useful article and it helped me see that my attachment is not only to material objects and people, but to theories and ways of thinking too.

  • Hi John–and Mike!

    That was actually my doing. I edited it to read as it does in this post, because that’s how I believed it was supposed to be written. Sorry about that Mike!


  • Allergyann


    I really enjoyed your thoughts on time. BTW, you are the only other person I know who has said,  “there more than one way to skin a cat”. Is your father from the Midwest?
    Thanks again

  • Allergyann

    Opps, sorry about the mistype. I meant your article on advice. Each day is a learning experience for following our own path.

  • Mike

    No big deal, Lori. I didn’t even notice the change.

    John, I’m with you on attachments to certain theories and ways of thinking. I know personally it has been challenging to change certain perfectionistic thought patterns.

    And Ann, thanks. My father is from Florida and he has been using that ” skin a cat” line since I was a youngin.

  • I too have been reading countless self-help and motivational blogs. Some expert may say A and some may say otherwise, but at the end of the day, it totally depends on what ur going thru and the circumstances…

    tq for this wonderful post!

  • Mike

    Thanks Syaf, Madison, Julie and Shannon. I agree with what all of you said. It can be a bit of a challenge to look within when everyone else claims they know what is best for us. I struggle with it all the time and I know others do as well. Knowing that can be comforting as it helps us realize we are indeed all in this together.

  • Tinarose29

    Very liberating!!!

  • ellie

    Thanks for writing this. Knowing which advice is right is the trial of my life. I suffer with it daily. I’m always looking for inspiration or answers. I even went to see a Tarot Card reader once. Now I’m testing out the theory that quieting the mind will produce answers from the heart/soul/universe. Starting now.