Hi Hannah,
I like what Elliedodge wrote – that by you being with him it will best the best gift. I think that’s pretty sweet.
Moving along that path, given you both like self development and he has fears, etc. one idea would be to get a private lesson doing / learning something together. Maybe Yoga would be relaxing and you both would benefit. No fears right?
Would travel and the arts be good? For example, a stay-cation to regional museums, theater, fairs, music performances?
One other thought is one about awareness and relationship development. You have not known each other very long, so by asking him questions and talking about interests, likes and dislikes, you could learn more about each other, and a birthday idea could pop out of the conversation.
Big blue