fbpx
Menu

Compassion or tough love?

HomeForumsRelationshipsCompassion or tough love?

New Reply
Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #45140
    septicon
    Participant

    This is about my sister who is forever in trouble, struggling, forever caught in pain and abuse and a very fast life! Since i was 17 (she is two years younger than me – now we are in our 40s!) i have had to deal with all the problems she has caused and saw our family turn upside down. She seem to go after everything that is damaging and bad events and she suffers. She has a huge self esteem issue as a consequent to being treated badly by people whom she allows to be used or she uses them i don;t know. she has always manged to keep us the family in the dark as to what is really going on in her life. But she never seem to have learnt from the mistakes and continues to blame us the family. She is very lasy too! My mother showed her compassion but mostly tough love. We did not support my sister as such, to her every whim and cry! However, she always managed to pull us all in emotionally by the click of her fingers even though she lived apart. I have grown with guilt as i have been placed in very difficult circumstances where i have had to make very difficult decisions in regards to her. This is ongoing. She is verbally abusive and constantly in trouble and does not want to change. it looks like on the one hand she is punishing herself, she has got involved with bad people and takes drugs. She was long time ago diagnosed with Bipolar but now there is no diagnosis???! I have never said to her how she really makes me feel and how i have ruined my peace and well being because half the time i am worrying or feeling guilty about her. But i have no idea how to help someone like this. None of us are able to change her. she is also manipulative. I now cannot tolerate her way of living and what she is doing to us as a family. I feel guilty that i cannot help her constructively. But instead i have decided to tell her that her wrong choices have affected us all and she must stop, ask her to seek help, prove that she can help herself first before i talk to her again, or have a relationship with her. Is this is the right thing to do? Am i being cruel to have made this decision? I will appreciate your valuable advice and guidance!

    #45159
    angiep
    Participant

    I am in a very similar situation with my younger brother. I am constantly trying to help him so that he doesnt hurt others. I do not allow him to take advantage of me but instead I provide him the basic amount of support needed for an individual to survive. I will give him food if he is hungry and point him in the direction of a warm place to stay but I will not allow him to live with me or take my money. He does however, take money from my sick, dying father whom I have to repay for what my brother has taken. In the long run I feel as if I am constantly being affected by his bad decisions. He was also diagnosed Bipolar. Regardless of what he does I still have a heart for him because he is my little brother. But, I know I need to protect myself which means setting limits and bounderies to what I will help him with. I must also see he is doing something for himself.
    I agree you need love yourself and don’t allow your sister to bring negative feelings to your life.

    #45189
    Noid
    Participant

    I have had a similar relationship with my sister, though different also. She found someone to share her life with who got sober, worked his programs and she got sober to be with him. She did not go to meetings or work out her inner demons but she seemed to put them to rest. After 20 years and 2 children he went back to his demons, was cheating on her with numerous women (and children) and eventually left her. He supported her as long as he could then died of cancer. She moved back to the states after he left her and we had a good relationship as she worked through her hurt and low self-esteem issues. Unfortunately, she started drinking again and while not as bad as when she was young, she still left her children in their apartment all night and well into the next day when she went out. I had the apartment next door but also had a social life and didn’t always know when she was absent. She hooked up with a heavy alcoholic who encourages her drinking but does not support her emotionally or spiritually. Before my father died, he arranged for my sister and I to buy a house together which we did mostly so her and her teenaged boy and girl didn’t have to live in a one bedroom apartment. Immediately thereafter my sister found out she had lung cancer. She has done radiation and chemo and is cancer free from her neck down. They discovered it had spread to her brain after she finished her lung treatment. She promised her children she wouldn’t die. And now I find she has gone back to smoking, which we both quit when she first found out she had spots on her lungs. She talks about healthy living, juices and takes natural cancer fighting foods but is still drinking almost daily and smoking packs of cigarettes. I have tried confrontation and it has caused terrible stress which, while bad for her, is bad for her children too. As they are the reason I got myself into living in the midst of the chaos, I think I need to release the need to help my sister. I believe her lifestyle will allow the cancer to kill her and I have to accept that that is her choice, even if she doesn’t see that it is going to kill her. I believe myself to be a feet to the ground realist and also believe my sister has always ignored reality whenever it did not coincide with her wants, or search for sensation. I and you Septicon, need to accept that these are her choices and try to help the rest of the family deal with them. Time alone will tell the outcome of her actions and in my sisters case, the cancer. Support your family, understand that what you tell your sister while she is under the influence is not going to be heard. It helps me to see her with a bottle over her head. Nothing gets through that the bottle does not let get through. In my case, its that anything she does affects anyone else or even herself. Try to stand united as a family and not get involved in the manipulations. She makes her own choices. They are not yours to make.

    #45242
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    hey septicon,
    you’re really the only one who can decide if this is the right thing for you at this point. one thing i use when i’m having difficulty knowing what’s right is i check in with my body.
    if the decision brings me a sense of love and peace then i trust that it’s the right thing for me in that moment, (always open for change too).
    when i was having difficulties with a family member i tried to give her the benefit of the doubt and see her trhough the eyes of compassion (and myself too). sometimes it takes a big cry to let it all out.
    i know how easy it is to worry about those you love but you deserve to be happy. practice reminding yourself that you don’t have to take care of everything. too much weight for you to carry. surrender it all to the universe or whatever you believe in. you’ll start to feel better
    hope this helps
    sending you love!
    carla

    #45406
    septicon
    Participant

    Thank you so much Angiep, Noid and Carla! I am so very grateful for you taking the time to share your stories and it has immensely helped me to make a decision! Very wise advice. God bless you all! :)))

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.