fbpx
Menu

Do we really care?

HomeForumsSpiritualityDo we really care?

New Reply
Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #93621
    Abhi09
    Participant

    Hello all.
    I am a final year engineering student from India.
    I am posting on this forum because I want to get the opinions of others regarding a seemingly weird but important issue which is neglected in our everyday life, something when encountered makes us think for a while but our state of helplessness w.r.t the issue makes us forget about it. I am talking about the injustice and cruelty going on in the world, and our apparent lack of empathy as reflected in our lack of actions.

    I am not even sure if this is the right forum to post about this, but I hope that fellow members would identify with my feelings after they have read the full post.

    To illustrate my point, let me talk about one issue which I feel strongly about- the farmers’ suicides in India. Although I had read previously about the plight of farmers in my country and the seriousness of the issue, I never really felt like acting upon it until I read an article. Here is the link to it for those interested in knowing about it.

    http://thelogicalindian.com/news/try-to-understand-why-we-die-a-farmers-wake-up-call-to-india/

    I won’t be going into the numbers here but on average, apparently 2 farmers commit suicide everywhere in India. And the thing which bugs me is that we all go on about our lives as if it is just something normal. That too, when our own existence and health depends on these farmers. I had tears in my eyes when I read this article and started to think about ways to do something about it, and realized that on ground level I can’t change the conditions – the government policies and their implementation, the corruption of the middlemen, the weather, etc. are the factors which actually affect the situation. The only thing I could think of is to post on social media on it. I thought of tagging famous personalities on twitter(politicians, actors, etc.) so that more and more people take cognizance of gravity of the situation. One point : The issue is well-debated on several news channels in India and the government has brought in some policy changes, so this issue is in general awareness, it’s just that most people are not aware of the astonishing figures of deaths and even if they are aware, the inability to make an impact prevents them(‘US‘) to take a step.

    This was about a month back. However, I have still not posted this on twitter. I was ‘trying to make time to draft a post which could force some people to take notice’. Almost every other day, the thought of doing something about it comes to my mind, but my own work takes priority and therefore I do nothing.

    Now, I have some questions. I would really appreciate if you could at least read them and think about it and give me some ideas.

    1. Do we strongly care about the world and its problems or do we read and think about these things because it brings some novelty in our lives/ it gives us a feeling of depth and of being in the present moment(awareness) in our fast lives/ it stimulates us intellectually ?
    I ask this question because even though I cried reading the article, I didn’t actually do anything about it – I found my own life with its fun, ‘problems’, etc. deserving of more attention than the issue.

    2. How should a person act in such a situation?Can I do something about the situation in North Korea? If not, should I just hope for the situation to improve and go on with my life?

    3. I know that such situations require administrative actions which are outside the realm of a common man, but then if we are so helpless, what is the point of taking action ever? We can just hope that none of us ever faces such a situation and live our lives in comfort tending to our needs and desires and those of our immediate family. I believe that we are already living like that, but this is what scares me – suppose I am in such a situation later in my life. How would I be feeling if the world around me was indifferent to my situation? Am I suppose to just continue to suffer hoping for some divine intervention?

    If you have read the full post, thanks for being so patient and kind. I feel guilty and helpless at the same time. Just need some suggestions to work on.

    #93746
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Abhi09:

    I read a good part of the article about India’s farmers plight, their pain and suicide rates and it is very sad. I think that your idea of putting the issue out there on social media is a good idea if you have a plan on how to help India’s farmers in danger of the financial devastation of loans that are impossible to pay, if you have a solution in mind for part of the problem if not all of it. Just putting it out there is not a good idea because cruelty and injustice are so very, very common that we, people, need not hear about more and more…if there is nothing we can do. If there is nothing we can do, our empathy is abused and we end up feeling more helpless. Money donations to so many causes are abused so often and so much of every dollar spent, that this is a consideration as well.

    I have an idea and if you agree with it, maybe you and I can join forces. This idea is not popular and highly controversial but I believe it is a good idea: to limit increase in human population, in other words: less births, less babies, less children… This applies not only to farmers in India but to any pregnant mother who is faced with circumstances that are very unfavorable to the future child: anywhere from mental illnesses, drug addictions, to … well, these two only- an epidemic in the U.S. are enough to consider- so my idea is discourage bringing new people into very unfavorable circumstances were the new people are very likely to suffer the pain of their parents.

    If you agree with me, I am willing to join efforts in reducing human population, let me know.

    anita

    #94052
    Abhi09
    Participant

    Dear Anita.

    You raised an interesting point that our empathy is abused when we can’t do anything about an issue. However, I don’t have a plan and this is why I want to raise awareness about this issue so that if somebody does have some ideas, he or she could act on it. But I do get what you are saying.

    Also, the main issue is to somehow bring about changes in government policies and their implementation so that the situation of farmers changes for the better. Your suggestion is something that can be applied to any family in circumstances unfavorable for another child, and therefore is not specific to the situation. But it is practical in the long run and therefore if we can spread awareness about it, then it could help save many families. If you need any help, I am up for it.

    The current Indian government is making some decisions that apparently, may bring about a positive change for the farmers.
    So, I am hoping for the best.

    #94096
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Abhishek:

    i do hope decisions to ease the pain of Indian farmers are made.

    More of my thoughts about helping the farmers, some specific ideas and some general as the suggestion I already made:

    International organizations, such as the UN will intervene in the business of a particular country if they decision makers (in the UN) consider the suffering of the people … catastrophic enough. They have their guidelines- I am supposing- of what constitutes a suffering severe enough to justify interfering with a country’s internal affairs, like human rights issues.

    Then I was thinking, the Indian government is not likely to listen to foreigners, people of other countries commenting on the country’s affairs and are more likely (although often not…) to listen to Indian citizens expressing outrage about what is happening in the country. So letting the decision makers know your outrage as an individual, gathering signatures, things like that… as seems to have been already done.

    Also, if let’s say, a group of the currently suffering farmers are chosen to receive money for life improvement of all farmers, the following is going to happen: if there is a possibility of abuse of that money, some of the now suffering farmers, the now victims, will become the victimizes of other farmers, and the money received by them will end up in a Swiss bank for their personal use, with a rationalization like: I suffered enough, now it is my turn to enjoy! This is human nature. So management of money directed at improving the life of farmers has to be micromanaged by conscientious people… that’s a tough one.

    It seems to me that the loans to the farmers, well, this is easy to figure, that the interests on those loans have to come down significantly. That is easy to figure, that it needs to be done!

    Please post again with updates and your thoughts!

    anita

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.