Home→Forums→Relationships→Breaking up with my best friend and first love
- This topic has 4 replies, 3 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 3 months ago by Jennifer Karl.
-
AuthorPosts
-
September 8, 2014 at 3:19 am #64530AnonymousInactive
So yesterday I broke up with my boyfriend who I was in involved with for 1 year and 2 months. We started seeing each other immediately and although we experienced a lot of ups and downs always found our way back to each other. We officially dated for the past 8 months. Both being in college in Dublin, but coming from two very different small towns far apart – when the college year ended we both choose to get jobs in Dublin together so we could spend more time together. I come from a very strict household, my parents are not very tolerant people and, unfortunately, have a racist strike in them. My boyfriend was half Turkish, so this immediately put a strain on things. I told them on one occasion about him, to which they were very annoyed and deeply concerned. I received no support from them and knew I couldn’t speak to them about this new relationship. When I made the decision to move to Dublin for the summer I told my parents that he has returned to Turkey for summer. In truth, my boyfriend gave up returning to Turkey for the summer months to spend time with me. His college course required him to travel from Ireland to Germany for a year to study and gain fluency in German – so we both felt the pressure to spend our precious summer months together because come September he was meant to leave for the year.
After much thought, my boyfriend differed college for the year and extended his contract working in Dublin. It seemed perfect – I’d return to college for my final year, he’d remain working until his contract ended in December then he’d leave in January to go to Berlin and learn German. From here he would return to his college degree.
We were crazy about each other, so much so that we decided to move into together. It seemed perfectly rational. We’d save money on rent and come college time I’d move back into my university accommodation and he’d move in with friends – but we’d still be a 2 minute walk from each other. Everything was great, better than great! He was my first love, my best friend, my first boyfriend- everything.
Like anyone we had problems; occasional fights, I’d get jealous, etc. Our biggest issue was the lack of sex. I enjoyed messing about and everything leading up to sex, but the sex itself was painful and uncomfortable. In all honesty, we tried only a handful of times because I used to get so frustrated with the fact we couldn’t enjoy having sex together – eventually we stopped even trying. The longer we lived together the worse the fights got. I can honestly say that in all the fights we had, I started most of them. I used to get so anxious and so sad, little things would drive me crazy. Looking back I feel such guilt for driving a wedge between us.
The last month of our relationship I felt pressure, not from him, but from myself. I felt like I should be having sex with him. But no part of me wanted to. It got to the point that any intimate contact and anything sexual made me uncomfortable – I’d start to panic and not want him to touch me. I began to hate touching him at all. It made me resentful if he felt aroused because I didn’t want to do those things. He used to be so patient and so understanding,but I just felt so bad I couldn’t do those things for him. Pressure also came from home. I found it increasingly hard to hide the fact that I had a boyfriend, that we lived together, that I was on a daily birth control pill; from my parents. I would return home each weekend and make up ridiculous lies about who I was with during the week, what I did, etc. I’d sneak out of the living room to take my birth control pill, I’d be afraid to leave my phone down in case they’d see a text from him! This sounds so ridiculous, but my parents pay for my college fees, they’re usually very supportive but they tend to be very close-minded and have a nasty racist side. They think of themselves as very traditional, very Catholic and very ‘proper’. I had weaved such a web of lies I couldn’t seem to backtrack. All the while I was getting more anxious and nervous.
Between all the fights, we had good days. He was after all my best friend, I had lied through my teeth to move up to Dublin to be with this guy – I left my job at home, settled for an average enough job in the City. However, I found myself very dependent on his companionship. I really missed him when I’d go home at the weekends, but when I’d see him during the week we’d fight all the time. I was so afraid of being on my own, but I was very unhappy. I couldn’t imagine being without him, but I felt like I was going to crack up. He was the most patient, most attractive person I’ve ever met. He was very caring and very considerate and he new I was unhappy. So last week he tried to pack up his things and stay with friends until his new place was ready to move into. During the day I was happy at the thought of having my own space and just meeting him occasionally and hanging out. But come the night, I’d get lonely and selfish. I used to beg him not to leave, I’d want him to stay the night.
This weekend I stayed here in the city for the first time in months. We had a nice time, went to a barbecue with friends and the zoo. But I finally had enough courage to break things off yesterday. I’m afraid, I’m sad. I feel guilty because he has deferred college for the year. I can’t bare to be here in work knowing that I left my old job back home for this one, all to be with him. I keep thinking how happy and excited we were a few months ago! His office is a 3 minute walk from mine. We used to get up at the same time,get the same bus into work, meet up for lunch, get the bus home together and spend all evening together. I’m trying my best not to text him or call him. I miss him so much and am so unsure of what to do. I really love him. My friends like him, but they know how intense things are. One friend in particular, a very good friend of mine, has never liked him. She’s also up here working in Dublin for the summer. She lives in the same apartment complex as me so she’s agreed to move in with me and keep me company. Her attitude towards my boyfriend was always that he was too intense, he moved things too quickly. I’m afraid to really listen to her because of her tainted view of him. A really big part of me wants to just go back to him. I’m so confused and so scared at the thought of really losing him. But then a part of thinks at least the break-up is over now and not when he leaves in January for Berlin (while I’ll be sitting a set of my final year law exams).
I’m not really sure why I wrote all this down. I just need someone to tell me what to do? I need someone to tell me where to go from here. I currently have 1 and 1/2 weeks left here in work. Then I’ve 4 days at home, then I’m back at college.
I really feel like I’m making a mistake leaving him. I’m just very confused and very sad. I want to tell him I’m sorry and I want him back, but I don’t know if its fair on him.
September 8, 2014 at 9:49 am #64579Jennifer KarlParticipantHi there Emma,
I saw your post and I’ve never written on any online forum or things like that but I really felt that I should try to help you any way I can because of how much your story reminded me of me and my first boyfriend. We lived in the same dormitory in college and we became fast friends and started dating soon after that. We saw each other everyday, studied together, and spent much of our free time hanging out. After two years, I started becoming very attached like you, always wanting to spend all my time with him, begging him not to leave at night, feeling left out if he had other plans that I couldn’t attend. I was very unhappy at this point and became anxious as well. I realized that I was unhappy because I became too dependent on him. Things became much better when I would go out with my own friends regularly, have days where I spent just with myself, and try to grow as my own person. We still spent lots of time together but I made it a point to have time for myself too. I’m not sure this is the case with you, but having a life outside of my relationship and focusing on myself was really beneficial for me. Maybe the fact that you two lived together wasn’t allowing you to have this ‘me time.’ My boyfriend and I never lived together but after spending a few weeks at his place before I moved into mine, I could see that it could be stressful and be the reason for the increase in arguing.
As for the trouble with sex, I can’t speak for everyone but for me, my first handful of experiences were similar to yours! At first painful but then as my body adjusted, it was no longer uncomfortable. But honestly it was months of figuring out what worked before I really started to enjoy myself. It takes time with your first and he seems to really care about you and be willing to put in the effort to make things work. Don’t feel the pressure to HAVE to do anything. Just remember that if he loves you he will understand! And from what you’ve said, your boyfriend seems very loving and understanding. At first, I used to feel bad too but then I realized that my boyfriend didn’t want sex for himself, he wanted to have it with me and it mattered more to him that I was comfortable and enjoying myself. I know its frustrating, but at least for me, it gets better with time and practice.
I’m really sorry your family isn’t supportive of your relationship and it makes complete sense why you are very stressed and anxious. When I first began my relationship I was sooo worried what my family would think, would they approve, etc. I wasn’t able to fully be myself around my boyfriend because I was holding off because of what other people thought of me. It took a long time (six month) for me to be comfortable enough to tell my parents and start calling him my boyfriend. But once I got it off my chest and stopped caring too much, everything was so much better! I realize that things are a lot more complicated for you with your family but maybe try to reach an understanding with them. I know its sometimes harder for the older generation to accept things that they were taught were ‘inappropriate’. But its not impossible! People can come to change their ideas with time and by the meeting and getting to know the people they are prejudiced toward. I know you might feel like they won’t understand, and maybe for a while they won’t, but if you really want to be with him and not have the stress of your family causing problems in the relationship, this seems like an issue you have to resolve.
In terms of him leaving and you staying to finishing your classes, I was in the same position with my boyfriend this past summer. I was struggling with the decision to break up before the summer so I’d have time to get used to being without him when he left for medical school across the country. So we decided to stop seeing each other romantically and hang out just as friends a month before he left. It was reallyyyy hard to accept and I was very upset for weeks crying everyday. But after a while it got better and having him in my life as a friend and still hanging out was much better than not having him in my life at all. I’m not trying to say that this is the right thing for you to do when the time come for him to leave, but know that just because someone moves away, it doesn’t mean that they have to be out of our lives forever. If you love him and want to be with him, don’t let the fact that he has to eventually move away for college stop you from being together now while you can. There is lots of time to figure out what to do when he has to move away.
I think the best thing you can do for yourself is take the next weeks before you start school and really think about all the things that are bothering you and try to sort them out on your own. Mediate on them, pray about them. I know you’re going to miss your boyfriend a lot but being apart for this short amount of time can be really beneficial in the long run. Maybe let your him know that you still care about him and want to be with him, but you need sometime to work things out by yourself. Its important to talk to friends, but DON’T let their opinions influence you too much. This is your life and you have to make yourself happy not your friend, your family, or anyone else. I’m not saying to completely disregard everyone’s opinion, but take what people say with a grain of salt. Having stress from family, living with your significant other, and moving things too quickly are things that cause couples problems all the time.
The fact that he decided to delay his studies means that he really wants to be with you. People don’t put off great opportunities like that for someone they’re lukewarm about. (Or at least most of the people I know wouldn’t) You seem to really love him as well and I think that if you’re able to work out the things that are causing you stress, you will be able to be in a happier and healthier relationship. Seeing as this is your first relationship, it would be crazy if there weren’t any bumps in the road. I really hope that you are able to work things out and whatever happens, in the end you that are happy!
Take care,
JSeptember 9, 2014 at 3:45 am #64627AnonymousInactiveThank you for your lovely reply, I really appreciate it.
I agree that taking some time to clear through the clutter in my head is necessary before returning to college. My ex and I agreed when we broke up that we’d meet 4 or 5 days later to return each others things we had left at one another’s. I’m nervous about meeting with him because I have so much love for him, I’m afraid I’ll crack and just want to get back together. I do think I need to be alone to become happy. Since we’ve broken up I have been shocked at how difficult I find doing daily tasks without him. When you mentioned that you too became dependent on your other half; it sent alarm bells off in my head! He said on a few occasions that I needed to learn to be happy within myself first and foremost.
Do you think that when we meet, would it be selfish to tell him to wait around until I’ve sorted things out? I don’t want to promise him if he waits a week or two then we’ll be back together and I’ll have sorted things out. Because I could sort things out and realize I need to be single. I’m so afraid if we got back together the same issues would arise (constant fights, lack of intimacy, lying to my parents). At the same time I don’t wanna lose him. I would be heartbroken if he wasn’t in my life, I’d just think of this summer and all our experiences with a shadow of resentment, if that makes sense! He has told me many times in the past that if we ever did split he could never be my friend, as with any of his exes. He said that the feelings he had during our relationship would just be too prominent and there’d still be attraction.
Can I ask something? The boy you were with recently (that you decided to just be friends with because he was moving away) was he the same guy from college?
How long did it take you to feel comfortable with your ex becoming your friend? It seems very difficult!
Again, thank you for all your help.
Emma
September 9, 2014 at 10:45 am #64640Anup DhirwanParticipantJennifer said right, to take sometime with yourself and sort all the things. Look at all the things and then sort it out on priority. Its really not a big deal to tell him to wait as its better than taking a wrong decision in hurry. He seems a decent guy and you both got career ahead beside love and family trouble so might be some tough decision on the card.
I have been in a one sided affair and I messed the things in hurry, but she was just too good to give me some time and think about how we are going to take our friendship. Well, its hard to go back to friendship when you have crossed that line but when you accept the reality of no-future in present situations then it becomes little easy.
I have been fighting with the truth since last 3 years and it took me just 3 months to accept the truth. I met her just last week after a gap of an year and everything feels normal. Feelings are still there but priorities have been changed to I prefer to not unearth them.
Take out all your thoughts on paper and try to solve it. That way you will feel if its somebody’s story and then you can take better decision.
All the Best!
September 9, 2014 at 8:47 pm #64663Jennifer KarlParticipantI think asking him to wait for you under these circumstances isn’t selfish at all at least not in a negative way. Being honest and saying that you need time to work on yourself and telling him that you would want try again when you are emotionally ready is the best way to give you two a fair shot at succeeding in the future. I think that anyone who cares about you will understand and want what’s best for you as well. You have to risk the fact that he might not want to get back together some time down the road in order to get to a place where you can be in a healthy relationship if he does. Like you said, if you get back together too soon, the problems might resurface. There are people that get back together over worse circumstances than yours and after being apart a long time. There’s also people don’t. Not to say that it is certain your ex will want to wait but its not like you’ve done something horrible and he does seem to love you a lot. I think that most people would give someone under circumstances like yours a second try.
I was the same way as your ex and NEVER thought that I could be friends with my ex. (the boy from college is the same one that I recently broke up with) People say that you can’t be friends with exs but honestly I think it depends on the circumstances of the break-up, how good of friends you were before, maturity level etc. This ex of mine isn’t friends with any of his exs before me so it all depends. So a month before he left we decided to break up but still see each other to hang out just without anything sexual. It was strange because I still felt the same way about him but had to hold back from kissing him, etc. The first month I constantly struggled with whether or not I wanted to have him in my life at all. At times, I would be so jealous of any female friends I’d see him with and I’d say to myself ‘I quit I don’t want to do it anymore.’ But then there were days where I wanted to talk to him or time he’d be the only person who I’d wanted to go to the beach with because he’s my best friend. I’ve lost touch with good friends before and I regret it that I let it happen. It didn’t make sense to me to lose touch with him too by cutting him out of my life since I knew he really cared about me and he was really trying to be my friends. Also I knew I wouldn’t see him again for 6 months to a year. But to be honest, I don’t know what I will feel if I see him again. Perhaps if we were still in the same area it would be too hard to be friends due to the attraction/jealousy. And I know there may come a time where we won’t be as close of friends because of new boy/girlfriends. I don’t want to underemphasize the struggle to get to this point (2.5 months) where the two of us are ok as friends. For me it’s been worth it, but I know for others it’s not worth the pain. Basically my point is you have to figure it all out for yourself when the time comes. You may think that being friends or not being friends is what you want, but then come to change your mind or realize that what you chose doesn’t work. I think that both ways involve a struggle and some heartache. All you can do it put in the effort, its up to him to accept it or not.
Just be honest with him about how you feel when you meet up and don’t feel bad about putting yourself first. To me, asking him to wait lets him know you still want him in your life but realize there are problems you need to address, which he should understand. Eventually, if you do give it a try again, try to take it slow and remember not to get too caught up in loving the other person that you forget about yourself. (I know that this easier said than done!) I don’t know if you heard of the movie Ae Fond Kiss, but parts of its story somewhat reminds me of yours. Maybe watching will give you a little courage and cheer you up 🙂
Wishing you all the best!
-
AuthorPosts