Broke up with the guy I love…

HomeForumsRelationshipsBroke up with the guy I love…

New Reply

This topic contains 5 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by  anita 4 days, 20 hours ago.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
  • #220969


    Just broke up with my boyfriend of 6 years and I feel awful.

    He was my first everything. He was nice, thoughtful and loved me more than I can tell.
    I loved him too.
    But he’s had a tough life and that led to him having insecurities. One of them was about the size of his package. Two years ago he told me about it and how he fantasized about me being with someone that could “really” please me. For two years I tried to convince him that he was all I wanted. As I said, he was even my first kiss and I just wasn’t comfortable with the idea of being with someone else just for pleasure, even less while being in a relationship. He would keep pushing me, telling me he was sure I would like it and it was what I needed, but I wasn’t feeling it and constantly told him so. He never acted on it, but he would tell me about how depressed he was that he “wasn’t What I deserved”.
    I stayed for two years having this conversation constantly, doing everything I could to help him without losing my values and without putting myself in a position I was completely uncomfortable with (being with someone else).

    Despite this he was an amazing guy, he was my rock when I really needed him and my best friend. He talked about marrying me all the time, and I would have been happy with that life.

    A couple of months ago the fantasy subject got pretty intense and I would lose my patience really fast.. how was it possible that I had to defend being faithful? We would fight constantly at night, regrettably I must admit it was through texts, we would both say we would try to be better and leave it at that.

    To me, the magic was gone. I still loved him very much but I wasn’t truly happy. I tried to tell him this a couple of times and he would tell me he’d try harder for me. He really did a lot to try and make me happy but something had changed for me. I kept thinking “it has to get better”, how could I feel so strongly about someone and not be happy with him?

    Then a couple of days ago we were fighting (in person) for something that wasn’t even that important, and he started yelling and I just told him “you know what? We are over, I can’t do this anymore” which I instantly regretted because I didn’t explain why I was doing it. When I tried to keep talking to explain what I was feeling he just dropped me off at my house (we were in his car) and asked me to please get out.
    I texted him a little later and I tried to thank him for everything he has done for me and tell him I’m here if he needs me, he replied saying “you always deserved better” which broke my heart because I only wanted him but he couldn’t see it.

    I’m really sad and scared about not having him in my life anymore, but getting back together would be selfish on my part because I cannot see a future while he still feels so strongly about his fantasy. What I do regret is hurting him, feeling like I’m abandoning him when he needs me. I believe he is broken from the experiences he’s had in his life and that I could have done more to help him, but at the same time I feel like I need to be a little selfish and think that it’s not fair for me to keep being unhappy thinking it will get better if I stay in a relationship with him.

    Yet, I still love him dearly. It breaks my heart to know it’s over, and it feels even worse knowing how devastated he is.



    Dearest Girl,

    I am really sorry about the lose he chose to have by letting you go,but it has nothing to do with you being selfish.

    If you just notice,it had just been you who was trying to keep it together all the time,you were making compromises to get a validation from him or by watching him be happy on the stake of your own happiness.

    The real catch in this relationship is that he was never sure about you from the very start,had he been he wouldn't have let you go(I donot mean to hurt you,but this is the truth)

    You loved him and this made you very much sure about being with him compromising all your needs,same applies at him as well,the person who loves you and is at the same page as you are,is rarely unsure.Practically,I can neither assume about his salary and stuff nor about your financial status but it would have been possible enough that you would have been helping him along if he had some financial hesitation.

    Since,the person had been somewhere trying to drag you out to go and see someone else or was mentioning about he doesnt deserve you kind of stupid remark,he actually meant it.Had he deserved you,he would have valued to stay and convince you to stay any way possible.

    You may also notice,if there would had been problems,you must have been the one taking efforts to confront most of the times,he would have hardly cared.Just,try to see a clear picture.Talking about getting married and actually wanting to get married are totally different.Had he wanted it to turn true,he would have been makimg efforts.

    The reason behind this could be either he was “benching” you by exploring other options meanwhile or he was never prepared to invest that much into your relationship.Think about this,try to visualise,donot be biased to actually view the situation on his perspective,rather give it a thought,was he actually investing his 100% in making you happy?

    Men are more clear in what they want and what they donot want mostly,they are less likely dragged by emotions than women are.

    As for the solution to test his words and his actions are relating or not try to maintain a “no contact ” .No texts,no calls,no begging back for a minimum time of 3 weeks.

    Most likely,you will find yourself getting back,peeping into or stalking him,DONOT DO THIS! Just donot even wait for him to text,do this till the time you are actually over the thought that you were being selfish,you werent being selfish.

    You will know how much love you deserve and how much self love you owe before all this ?




    Dear A:

    You wrote: “I only wanted him but he couldn't see it”. Throughout the years you've been with him, he didn't see it that you only wanted to be with him.

    You wrote: “I could have done more to help him”. But all that you have done… didn't help him. If you stayed longer with him, he wouldn't be helped, I don't think.

    “it feels even worse knowing how devastated he is”. It is very sad that he is devastated and that he has been devastated for so long, way before you entered his life. It is heart breaking to watch a person being devastated and to be able to do nothing about it. His emotional injury preceded you. You didn't create it.

    Unless he attended quality, individual psychotherapy for himself, If you stayed with him or got back with him, his pain will not decrease, but yours will increase.




    Dear Eos and Anita:

    thank you both for replying to such a long post. Your insight has helped me see things a little clearer.

    It still hurts, but I know the wound is fresh and that I need time to heal properly. Even tho the sadness for the loss of a loved one is there, the guilt has faded a little because I did try my hardest to help him, there was nothing else for me to do and he wasn’t willing to see a professional.

    For the meantime I’ll try to follow your advise, specially about not letting myself contact him or stalk him on social media.

    Thanks again,




    Dear A

    Prayers for your strength as you heal.

    Take care of yourself.



    Dear A:

    You are welcome. I hope you post again with your thoughts and feelings in the days to come. I would like to read about how you are progressing through this post break up and reply to you if and when you post again.





    I have been with my partner for almost 8 years and like in this story I became jealous of him so badly that I would point out other women to him that he might like. Yesterday he moved out to a rented place in order to think about things. We bought a house together 4 years ago. I'm lost without him as I love him very much and I am worried he will not want to be with me.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.