fbpx
Menu

How am I always wrong

HomeForumsRelationshipsHow am I always wrong

New Reply
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #358689
    Alwayswrong
    Participant

    Hi, I have been married for 16 years. I am an Indian and married into Indian conservative family. From the day one my mother in law made in uncomfortable, with her comments and her looks . Although I was 24 when I got married but was totally naive. When I got married I decided, I will do everything my best . And I think that a huge mistake I made. After I got married I tried to please everyone, my husband , my Mother In Law(MIL) . But I however much I did I saw she was never happy. After I got married I moved to USA as my husband was working and living here. My inlaws used to visit us every year. I used to dress according to how my MIL liked , we would eat what they liked, we would only go to places where they could go. We used to reject friends invitations if my inlaws were not invited. I would not shop when they were here because my inlaws used to think I am wasting money, My husband told me to shop in secrecy without them knowing about it. And I followed . My MIL would not talk to me properly sometimes , it came to point when my husband stopped talking to me when they were here , he would not talk to me for the whole time while they were here and try to reconnect after they left . This started issues between me and him . Its only after I got pregnant and delivered my son I realized I was not respected and valued in the house. And I that realization hurt me and I started to change. I became this hard , loveless individual. I hate my MIL from the bottom on my heart . I used to burn inside every time I used to see her . Few things she did when my son was born made me realize she is a selfish and self centered person. She came to help me after delivery, within a month she started saying that she was there not to work but for her grandson. We had huge fight because I used to be in my room as it my first experience and I didn’t know how to breastfeed , He would not latch . I used to be up in the night so I used to come downstairs late in the morning, she used to hate that . When my son was with her and if I was around and my son would look towards me , she would turn his heard the other side so he would not look at me . She did the same to my mother once when we were in India. Another thing my inlaws never respected my parents always had issues with my parents. The resentment inside me kept growing, its still there . My husband never supported me and always said that I am wrong in whatever is happening . He told me that I am messing up all his relationships. He told me I cannot keep any relationship. Always negative and always made me feel that whatever is happening around me is my fault. The result is I have low confidence , I do not feel like talking to people thinking I may screw up if I say something wrong. Things were never the same we fought and made up ..fought and made up ..still together i had my second kid ..the only thing I have achieved over the years of fighting is some respect in the house. I can shop how I want . I can dress  how I want (although I don’t when they are around to prevent any issues). However the thing I am not able to change is my hatred towards my MIL . Sometime the way she says things and the things she says really hurt . I try to just ignore but when I am PMSing , I just cannot take it and back answer her. Again the whole cycle starts . My husband tells me he cannot live with me because I have anger issues. And he will not talk to me for weeks and life goes on. It used to affect me a lot .It still does but now I try to keep happy face and try to spend my time with my kids. Looking back in my life I have suffered and I am still suffering. The only think that helps me survive are my kids . In my 16 years for whatever that have happened in my life my husband has always blamed me.

    #358701
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Alwayswrong:

    After reading your story, I am certain that you are far from being Always wrong.

    What you described is what I read again and again regarding Indian marriages: the husband’s mother owning her son and her son’s wife and their children. This ownership is often, from my over five years experience in these forums, in the heart of the “Indian conservative family”. It happens in other cultures as well, and it happens in every country, but it is more common in some conservative societies than in others.

    Your mother in law owns her son, who is .. her son first, and your husband a far second.

    You live in the US, and of course, the times we are living in are generally not good times, pandemic, a terrible economic crisis, civil unrest.. so it’s not a good time to make a life on your own, as a divorced mother, is it?

    I mean, in better times, maybe that would be a possibility for you, to divorce this man (who is his mother’s son, not really his wife’s husband and partner)?

    anita

    • This reply was modified 3 years, 10 months ago by .
    #358717
    Alwayswrong
    Participant

    Thank you Anita for responding . But my kids are small right now and I do not want them to suffer . I am not looking for Divorce right now. But it is so hard to deal with the same things over and over . Especially when you do not see any resolution.

    #358718
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Alwayswrong:

    I understand. What do you think about the ownership part of what I wrote to you, that your husband is owned by his mother, and that he is  her son first, and your husband a … far second?

    anita

    #358719
    Alwayswrong
    Participant

    You are right about the ownership part , Indian In-laws think when they marry their son they buy a living puppet. It’s good that I am educated and I work.

     

    #358721
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Alwayswrong:

    Unfortunately for me, I spent decades of life being owned by someone else, in a similar way that you are owned by your MIL. I know the frustration of living like “a living puppet” and the anger and hatred involved. We humans cannot be content being owned.

    Like you, I too “do not see any resolution” beyond what you already resolved.  Your husband is owned by his mother and he directs his anger at you, not at his mother; he blames you, not his mother. The best he does for you is to suggest that you shop in secret, so to not annoy his mother.

    An independent, free man, one who is not owned by his mother, will encourage you to shop in the open, not in secret.

    The reason I mentioned divorce is not because I think that it is something you can do, with two young children, but because like you, I don’t see any other resolution. If you were able to live separately from your husband and his owner, then it would have been a good solution. (You mentioned that your children would suffer if you got divorced, but they must be suffering seeing their mother suffering. Even if you try to hide it from them).

    The way it is, within the marriage, you can’t break the bond between your MIL and her son, and get him to be on your side. I don’t think the woman in power, in this context (his mother) will be willing to give up her power, and I don’t think that her son is able to stand up to her.

    But if they, your MIL and her son, saw that you are a woman able to live independently of them with your children, then they may change their behavior toward you. People that are about power, like your MIL, is not likely to listen to reason; not likely to be willing to have empathy for you. She is likely to listen only to counter-power.

    Again, I am not suggesting that you get a divorce. I am exploring ideas and thoughts with you.

    anita

    #358772
    Anonymous
    Guest

    testing

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.