fbpx
Menu

My silent passive aggressive sister. Help.

HomeForumsRelationshipsMy silent passive aggressive sister. Help.

New Reply
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #223683
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Ok, so I really need some wise advice from all you fine people. I feel like I’m losing my mind because my gut tells me my adult sister works behind the scenes with my family members, esp. my brother, dad, and mother to ensure her status is one of being the most nurturing, and therefore most loved in our family. Something tells me she is not honest with me about really simple things that no one need “forget” to mention or neglect to tell me – except for one specific situation.

    A couple of things over the years have happened that i’ve always given her the benefit of the doubt:

    – my dad was diagnosed with cancer a month or so ago. he’s had surgery and is on the mend. my sisters husband is a doctor who my dad confided in because he didn’t want any drama. i  was the last of my whole family to know. whatever. it hurt a lot but it’s not about me. anyways, i kind of freaked out because of course my sister would know if her husband knew but she told me she had no idea. my gut tells me she did and didn’t want to tell me. Why? Is this normal? How could she not know?

    my sister is in constant contact with my brother but denies she has been. i am jealousmofmtheir relationship. he asks for her advice and doesn’t include me.

    my sister loves to be the most liked and most loved of the family. she is a great person that does a lot of great things for everyone including myself. however, anytime i reach out to a family member and have a nice chat i just mention it to her and she automatically follows up with a  call or email herself. am i being paranoid or is she passive aggressively being competitive? My gut tells me she is.

    our family reunion is coming up and my brother whom i’m not very strong as far as a relationship goes, has mentioned tonight that he is coming into town from a long ways away. i would love to know he is in town and only found out tonight he might be! my sister was going away the same day as the family reunion, but told me she booked her flight for later because she found a better deal. i checked the airline prices and her new departure date is more expensive. she neglected to mention that my brother may be coming into town and would be staying at her house as he always does. this also bothers me a lot. why not stay at my house? it’s only Forty five minutes away. he says it’s closer and easier for him.

    what bothers me about this pettiness and lies is that she is my sister. i am straight forward with her but she is not with me most of the time. how do you deal with someone like this that you can’t help but love but makes you crazy, angry, and hurt by excludingmand almost coveting family relationships?

    She told me once in a car trip in front of her kids that she knows how to lie and tell people what they want to hear, and she says she’s good at it! I’ll never forget that. I am not like that. How can i trust anything she says now? When i confronted her about all this, she always knows what to say in a diplomatic way to the point that i so want to believe what she’s saying and that i’m the crazy, paranoid, over sensitive one. I want to see the good in people, esp. my family, but there is so much subtly in the lies and in what is not said that my red flags go up constantly. it’s draining and it’s making me sick. i distanced myself from her but i love her so much that i can’t help but forgive over and over of what i think she’s doing and that i’m the crazy one. i don’t trust her though deep down. i now don’t trust myself, my gut response for fear that i may lose her entirely.

    face to face discussions dontmwork. she’s much more clever than i and i always seem to fold because i want everything to be ok between us. i really feel like crap.

    please, i would love some advice.

     

    lispol

    #223697
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lispol:

    She told you that “she knows how to lie and tell people what they want to hear, and she says she’s good at it”, and that is all she said, in a confident, proud voice?

    She didn’t add that she doesn’t like that about herself, that she is bothered by lying, that she wants to be honest?

    If the answer to my first question is yes and to my second question, it is no, then she lies and is proud of it, therefore, she is not motivated to change. She is motivated to continue to lie.

    You asked: “How can I trust anything she says now?” – if you continue to try to trust her, you will continue to feel that you are “the crazy, paranoid, over sensitive one” and therefore you will continue to “feel like crap”.

    You “so want to believe what she’s saying”, but you shouldn’t.

    You stated that you love her so much and you are afraid to lose her. If you can manage to not lose yourself (to the belief that you are crazy, paranoid and over sensitive), then keep her in your life. If you continue to lose yourself, you lose what matters most to you, and that is, you.

    As you communicate with her and observe family events happening, did you try to be in peace with the fact that she lies, that she tells people what they want to hear and succeeds in appearing to be the favorite, the one most esteemed, and you the way less favorite and esteemed than her? If so, how did it work- or not- for you?

    anita

     

    #223729
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hi Anita,

     

    Thank you for your good insight.

    I suspect that at this time i am not yet strong enough to be able to differentiate when she’s lying or not and that makes me crazy and has caused me many sleepless nights being bipolar. i believe i just need to pull myself away for a bit to recharge, strengthen myself and my family for my own mental health.

     

    its just that i fear that if i do this, the bonds between my sister and brother will get stronger and i’ll miss out. she loves the attention she gets from family and is always so proud that her husband is a doctor whom she brags about. my sister is the much loved one as she is the most involved with our family. me, i’m always worrying i’m not good enough. not self pity. i actually feel like i am not good enough and desire the same status as my sister.

    my sister said yesterday that i have a big heart and i wear it on my sleeve. how do i not do this?

     

    #223731
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    oh and the answer to your first question is yes. 🙁

     

     

    #223733
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lispol:

    You are welcome. In what context did your sister tell you that you have a big heart and what do you think she meant by you wearing it on your sleeve?

    anita

    #223749
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    We were talking about an ex-friend of mine. This so called friend was emotionally and financially manipulative. Anyways, she’s no longer a friend. I seem to attract these types of people.

    #223753
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lipsol:

    Maybe it is not that you attract dishonestly manipulative people, maybe there are just so many that they end up in your life because of sheer numbers. Notice your sister herself is dishonestly manipulative, telling people lies so to make them feel good. And it is not that you attracted her into your life, you were born into the situation.

    Did your sister consider you having a big heart a disadvantage, was that her message to you?

    anita

    #223777
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hmmm…i don’t really know. I hope not. I really just try to see the good in people, naive yes.

    #223815
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lipsol:

    You wrote about your sister, “her status is one of being the most nurturing, and therefore most loved in our family… the most liked and most loved of the family”. You envy her status. You wish you had her status.

    She told you that she lies to people, expressed pride in successfully lying to people, telling them what they want to hear. You suspect that is what she does with her own family, parents, siblings, you and that is part of her having achieved her status. You suspect her to be “silent passive aggressive”.

    My suggestion is that you give up trying to match her status in your family. Admit defeat and give up the quest to compete with her status. Withdraw from the competition and put some distance between you and your sister/family.  Slowly, make a life for yourself elsewhere where you are honest and appreciated, involved, liked and loved.

    anita

     

    #223855
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Anita,

     

    These are wise words and 100% true.

    I am meeting with her to discuss these issues shortly, although I’m not sure that I should but I feel that I need to clear the air. I am a straightforward person and my feelings get hurt easily so i take affront when i feel there are things going on in the background that i know nothing of. I have a list of what to say but i’m not sure if i should say them.

    what do you think?

     

    #223859
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lipsol:

    I think that it is not a good idea to talk  to your sister. How can talking to a person who lies and takes pride in lying resolve any of your issues..

    I think you should put distance between you and your sister, not reach out to her once again. It worked against you in the past (causing you to feel like “the crazy, paranoid, over sensitive one… like crap”), and it will work against you once again.

    anita

    #223863
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    but i feel like i should clear the air and get her to admit there is a rivalry which has caused me to become envious. she holds her cards close where i do not.

    #223865
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lipsol:

    There was a bird outside my closed bedroom window that kept flying into the window, hit it, but flew again into the closed window, trying to get through and into the room. Every time it hit the window (and I assume it hurt), it reversed and repeated, again and again and again. Eventually it died.

    I understand the drive that you have to get clarity from the same person that repeatedly brought about the confusion, the feeling that you are crazy. The bird had that motivation, to achieve the impossible. It didn’t work for the bird and it won’t work for you.

    anita

    #223919
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Anita,

     

    You did me a world of good today with your advice. I did meet with my sister but I kept it lighthearted and just said “what i was going to speak to you about stems from insecurities on my part”, so let’s just keep today centred on our kids.

    I said “the worst thing you could do would be to feel sorry for me having to deal with bipolar issues”. She said in no way does she feel sorry for me because I have everything that a lot of people don’t have (good house, food, supportive family (hmm…I didn’t say anything when she said that). She also said this does not mean that I think you need to pull your socks up (although I know she did).

    Anyways, I thought a lot about what you and my husband said today and I just felt I needed to tKe the high road.

    Anita, you and my husband saved me today from myself. I can’t thank you enough.

    Much love. I hope your weekend will be blessed with the things and people you need. You are a wise and compassionate person.

    #223957
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Lipsol:

    You are welcome and thank you for your kind words and good wishes.

    Better indeed that you no longer seek clarity from the person who offers confusion, better not seek a solution from the person who generates the problem.

    I hope you post again anytime you want to, if you do.

    anita

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.