fbpx
Menu

Criticism in relationships

HomeForumsRelationshipsCriticism in relationships

New Reply
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #98102
    Wendy
    Participant

    I’ve been in a relationship for 3 years now and my boyfriend and I love each other very much. However, he keeps
    criticizing me all the time, from small things like peeling potatoes right to larger issues like being too much of a doormat. I do realize that I have these flaws, and what he says is perfectly valid, but sometimes, the weight of all these criticisms is too overwhelming for me. I’ve talked to him about it and asked him to let up a bit, once in a while, but he says it is the truth and asks me why I am afraid of facing the truth.

    I’ve also asked him several times if he sees any positive traits in me and his answer is that it is up to me to discover myself and he is not going to mollycoddle me and tell me anything to soothe my ego.

    My question is – Am I overreacting or being too sensitive? I don’t really have any friends to talk to about this, at the moment. I would love to hear from any of you kind folks out here on Tinybuddha about situations like these.

    Thanks for reading!

    #98109
    PathOfPeace
    Participant

    Hey Wendy,

    Reading your post made me angry. Why? Because its very rude of him to 1. be on you like white on rice about every little flaw (which we all have) 2. not give you props on the good things you have to offer (When he clearly offers up the bad) 3. I dont know what mollycoddle means….

    Anyways, My reply is NO. Your not being overreacting or too sensitive. My advice is to tell him the classic line “If you have nothing kind to say, dont say anything”. As far as “facing the truth” just because he throws his opinion around doesnt mean its FACT. Tell him that, defend yourself. What might seem like a little problem after 3 years will be a real big problem in another 2 or 3 years if he doesnt fix his negative feedback because you will grow tired of the put downs.

    Best of Luck, you deserve better. I as a man dont do that to my wife and wouldnt.

    #98112
    HippieChick
    Participant

    If you ASK him about a particular trait and he feels there’s room for improvement then I think he’d be justified in telling you. Or if there’s a situation that he sees you being taken advantage of… (you mention being a “doormat”). Otherwise I think I’d have to have a serious discussion about the inappropriate way he talks to you. I mean, seriously, who makes that big of a deal about how another person peels potatoes…at least you’re doing it and he doesn’t have to! If he can’t be more positive and less critical you may want to reevaluate your relationship.

    But, before you do that, make sure you’re not inadvertently doing the same thing…constantly pointing out his flaws or things he does “wrong”. It’s an easy habit to fall into.

    Good luck and I hope you can resolve this issue!

    #98119
    Wendy
    Participant

    Dear PathofPeace and HippeChick,

    Thank you so much for your kind thoughts.

    PathofPeace, I do feel weary several times already. You’re right about the fact that it will grow to be a bigger problem later.

    HippieChick, Personally, I follow the same principle that you suggested – I don’t criticize or nitpick unless my input is specifically asked for. And yes, he does point out when I am being taken advantage of for which I am really grateful. Which is why, when I do ask him to tone down the criticism, he says he will stop pointing out these things as well.

    #98127
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Wendy:

    Can you imagine if you marry him (please don’t!) and this is his child rearing philosophy: ongoing negative criticism and nothing positive to say? You will be raising very anxious, unwell children!

    So… please do not marry him and have children with him unless he makes a 90 degree change and sticks with the change for good.

    It is not healthy for you to be in a relationship with a man with this life philosophy either, even though you are not a child.

    anita

    #98130
    Wendy
    Participant

    Hi Anita,

    Thank you for your response. I’ve been feeling like a child asking for positive feedback since he says I should toughen up.

    It really gives me some peace to hear that my requests are not unreasonable and confidence to stick up for myself.

    #98131
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Wendy:

    Yes, do stand up for yourself! And if he doesn’t back off and stops negatively criticizing you, maybe you should consider ending the relationship?

    Make it clear to him that he needs to stop with the criticism, that you will not tolerate it!

    Hope you do and he responds with a changing of his … unwise policy!

    And do post again with an update, perhaps…?

    anita

    #98146
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Dear Wendy,
    It saddens me when I read your post! And the answers is no you are not being over sensitive and you should trust what your guts is telling you!

    When people feel the need to criticise others so heavily it is usually an issue they have within theirselves.
    He clearly has issues as he feels the need to project his negativity on to you and make you feel bad about yourself so he feels good about himself.

    I would make it very clear to him that you will not be treated, spoken to or bullied in such away and you will not allow him to make you feel lacking in your self worth/esteem.

    If he does not life you up then you need to speak to him and ask him in a calm way why he feels the need to put you down and if he cannot say anything nice then don’t say anything to you at all. If he can’t respect your wishes then I would question if he is the right man for you?
    Critical men will turn into controlling me and you do not want to be in a controlling relationship full stop as that will lead to other issues!!!

    I do hope you can make him understand how he is making you feel and if he loves you so much he will see how much he is upsetting/hurting you and stop!

    Good luck and please know how great you are and don’t let anyone else tell you better!!!

    #98291
    Wendy
    Participant

    Thank you, Anita and H1978

    Your words of support and advice are heart-warming.

    I did speak to him yesterday about it and after a loooooong conversation, he agreed to cut back on the criticism.
    He does have a lot of issues himself so he has agreed to focus on them more and pick on me lesser.

    I hope things take a turn for the better.

    Thanks once again to everyone who were kind enough to reach out to me!

    #98300
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Wendy:

    You are welcome… anytime!

    Am I too ambitious for you when I suggest here: that he not only “cut back on the criticism”- but eliminate it? That is once he thinks it (and he will) to control himself and not put those thoughts into words said to you?

    anita

    #98360
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Dear Wendy,
    Glad to be of help and if he continues with his criticism I would simply reply calmly “As we spoke about, clearly you have something going on with yourself, so I will leave you to it as I won’t allow you to project it on me”

    All the best and remember, do not put up with his put downs and let him project his issues on you xxx

    #98786
    Wendy
    Participant

    Dear Anita and H1978,

    Thank you so much for your responses.

    After that talk, he has withdrawn a lot from me, and we haven’t spoken for about a week now. He refuses to pick up my calls.

    One thing that he told me repeatedly was “Criticism is how I show people that I care. I wouldn’t criticize you if I didn’t care deeply and believe so much in the fact that you have room for improvement”. He believes that he uplifts people by pointing out their flaws and by rejecting this trait of his, I am more or less saying that I have a big problem with who he is.

    Personally, I think there is more to any person than the ability to point out other people’s flaws, and I do feel that he is limiting himself by defining his worth with something so narrow. But right now, he feels rejected and I am afraid he might leave me to turn to others who are “in need of him”

    Any thoughts on what I should do? It hurts to stand between a rock and hard place.

    thanks in advance,

    Wendy

    #98788
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hello Wendy,

    There needs to be a healthy and respectful balance when it comes to constructive criticism. To criticize lovingly to help and improve someone who may be having a difficult time is one thing but to criticize in order to cut somebody else down to make you feel better, is not healthy or respectful at all.

    If my partner were to ask me what positive traits I see in her, I would be happy to answer her and tell her of all her positive traits that she exudes and carries. If he/she cannot do that, then there is something wrong with this person. I personally feel that it’s not a difficult answer to give to the woman you love.

    You’re not over-reacting or being too sensitive, as open communication with your partner is vital for a strong, loving and healthy relationship to succeed. The reason why we fall in love with a person in the first place, is because of all their positive traits they exude.

    Wendy, my thoughts about what you should do, is to tell him how you are feeling but since he won’t pick up your calls, that in itself is a very immature way to behave towards you. Someone who truly loves their partner and wants the best for them, is to be communicative and willing to rationalize while calmly listening to you from a loving stand-point. Love is about coming together and being selfless, while working as team with each other and not working against each other by constantly pointing out their flaws.

    If he’s not willing or able to have an equal, respectful, loving, communicative and most importantly non-judgmental relationship with you. Then it’s best you let him go, you don’t deserve someone who’s going to cut you down, cut you off by not wanting to be communicative towards you and most importantly you don’t need or want someone who just doesn’t care to want to have a healthy and fulfilling relationship with you.

    Please let us know how you are doing and you’re more than welcome to come and post/talk to anyone on here at anytime. I may not be around due to work but there are many loving people here, who are willing to support you the best way they can with their helpful advice.

    Sending you lots of love, positivity and light your way.

    M.

    #98805
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Wendy:

    I think that your boyfriend, now giving you the “silent treatment” for a week, may very well be a dishonest man.

    You wrote: “One thing that he told me repeatedly was ‘Criticism is how I show people that I care. I wouldn’t criticize you if I didn’t care deeply and believe so much in the fact that you have room for improvement’. He believes that he uplifts people…”

    I challenge his statement for honesty. One thing parents often say to their children as they beat them up, even severely beating them, is “I am doing it for your own good.” Do they?

    I am challenging his intent in his negative criticism. I am suggesting negatively criticizing people repeatedly, as he has done, is not an expression of his love, of his caring deeply for the person. I think he does the negative criticism because it makes him feel good. It relieves him from his own distress, lets him get rid of steam.

    Another point is: who is HE to point out to others how THEY should improve? Who made him the authority? Does he has a certificate from the University of Perfection authorizing him to take on the job of walking around this earth pointing to others’ imperfections?

    What do you think?

    anita

    #98811
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Wendy:

    If he is honest and he truly believes in his heart and mind that ongoing negative criticism is an act of love, are you willing to believe it too?

    He may be honest, maybe, about how he feels, to the best of his understanding, but are you willing to live under the ongoing negative criticism? Under a reduced amount of it? And are you willing to bring children into the world, children he would deeply care about by negatively criticizing them?

    Will those future innocent children feel his deep caring when he negatively criticize them again and again? Or will they feel that they can’t do anything right and develop a low, low self confidence?

    And is he avoiding you now, giving you the “silent treatment” as a threat: Take my negative criticism or I will never talk to you again?

    Is that a threat you are willing to live with: my-way-or-the-highway?

    anita

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 20 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.