fbpx
Menu

Helping Relatives

HomeForumsRelationshipsHelping Relatives

New Reply
Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #49644
    Priscilla
    Participant

    Hi Guys,

    I’m not sure where to post this but I think this counts as relationship issue. So, I just want to know how you define the boundaries in helping others, or for the purpose of this post, your relatives specifically.

    Both my parents grew up in the middle to lower class but they and most of their siblings have managed to earn decent living, some even earn a very comfortable one but there’s this one maternal aunt who is the least well-to-do. My maternal grandparents raised their kinds (all girls) with a Cinderella mindset. From what I know, this aunt isn’t particularly smart and she’s made a series of bad decisions that’s landed her as a single mother with three kids. She is uneducated (only a high school grad), she works odd jobs (my mom just told me she now sells lemonade and snacks to school children for a living), her husband left her without financial support, and unfortunately, her eldest kid got pregnant as a teenager and is now married with two kids to her baby daddy, who is also a poor fella.

    I’m sure my extended family helps her whenever we can, the thing is, she isn’t one to shy away from asking for handouts, she isn’t shy to paint herself in a very pitiable manner, and sometimes would use guilt trips or be passive-aggressive. Of course we all understand her predicament but I think we just want her to get her act together and somehow get out of her Cinderella mindset.

    Now that I’m already working, I could also contribute to helping her but I just wanna know how to define the boundaries. I don’t want to perpetuate her habit of receiving handouts because I think it would be better if she could be self-sufficient. I think a lot about how lucky I am that my family emphasized on education and self-sufficiency and that makes me want to help her so bad because I think she never had the chance, but then I see her and think to myself that this is all her own doing.

    So, to recap, anyone with similar experience please share how you define your boundaries in helping others. Also, any tips on how to be graceful when you don’t feel like helping? I’ve seen people who are so afraid of being bothered that they come off rude / cruel, i don’t wanna be that person.

    Thanks!

    #49793
    Mark
    Participant

    Priscilla,
    You are conflicted with showing compassion for your aunt and wanting compassion for yourself as well.
    I would like to take the perspective of loving yourself.
    You do not want to feel forced to prove your compassion to your aunt by her begging.
    It is not compassion when you do it on demand.

    You can help your aunt by teaching her to “fish” rather than giving her fish all the time.
    There are resources that can assist her I am sure, e.g. churches, social agencies, charties.
    You can offer to babysit or drive her to jobs.
    You can point her to community college programs that will help her get better paying jobs or even the state employment dept that have programs that assist people.

    Insofar as what to say to her. You need to be clear about it within yourself before you set boundaries. If you have guilt or feel conflicted on on what to do then that will come across regardless what you say.

    A simple “I’m sorry but no.” without further need to explain yourself may be sufficient. You can offer to help or support in other ways but only if you really want to. You may have to repeat that refusal but no need to elaborate.

    Hope that helps.

    Mark

    #49921
    Priscilla
    Participant

    Hi Mark,

    Thanks for your input & perspectives. I was supposed to meet this aunt, alas, my flight got cancelled (as you perhaps know from my other post in this forum) so I get to face this problem of helping her some other day.

    With me, she only ever asked for some spare cosmetics or hand-me-downs, she never begged for money but I heard she does that to her siblings.

    Anyway, I agree that it’s better to teach someone how to fish. I’ll see what I can do next time I meet her, hope I could find a way to knock some sense into her without sounding holier-than-thou. Sometimes it’s hard to do because you know, this is my aunt, somebody who was once an ‘adult’ to me and now I could say that I perhaps have surpassed her in a way..

    Cheers & Love!

    #49923
    Nia
    Participant

    Hello Pricilla!

    It may be very difficult for you to even “inspire” your aunt to change her mentality. It may no be your place to do so anyway. No matter how delicately you try to change her, she will turn on you once she realizes it and she will be more resistant to change.

    However, one way to really help her is to guide or coach her children (as an older, respected cousin) to out grow such mentality. If that’s how their mother is, it is more likely that they will adapt her mentality and attitude. You can be an example to them and show them that they can choose to think differently. Show them that they can choose a different path; a path towards abundance, self respect and self sufficiency. Of course be sensitive enough that when you do this, you do not destroy the children’s respect towards their mother. Nothing good will come out of that.

    Here’s a tricky lesson I learned recently: Sometimes people do not need your help nor do they need you to fix them. Sometimes they only need to be loved. And loving someone doesn’t always mean fixing them. Fixing problems for others will rob them of the opportunity to know themselves better and grow.

    From what I see, maybe you can also start by gently teaching your aunt to love her self more. When she learns that, she will be more willing to let go of self-defeating thoughts, attitudes and habits.

    Nia

    #50419
    Priscilla
    Participant

    Hi Nia,

    Thanks for your input. The thing is, I live in a different country now so that would make your advice a little bit more difficult to do… 🙂 Sometimes I just wish she could get a steady job albeit a low-paying one, at least it’s better than doing random odd jobs. I have another aunt (her sister) who is also a single mother with two kids but she managed to get herself a steady desk job so her situation is better. We just don’t know why this particular aunt couldn’t at least follow that path, like she has a mental blocking or something.

    Cheers!

    #50554
    Janet
    Participant

    My mother had a sister just like this. Our family took her in for several months. It was a miserable experience as she was demanding, selfish, and openly flirted with my father. My parents helped her for years, moving her and paying for her apartments. She had two daughters who never contributed a dime to her support. You can only help people who really want help. You are under no obligation to take care of this woman. If you decide to become involved, she may take advantage of you forever.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.