fbpx
Menu

I broke up with my boyfriend for my parents.

HomeForumsRelationshipsI broke up with my boyfriend for my parents.

New Reply
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #278881
    treasamariam
    Participant

    I am a 21-year-old chartered accountancy student.I was in a relationship with my boyfriend who is my two years older senior. I was having a four months relationship. Before that, we were best friends for months. We both share the same religion, caste and somehow equal financial background. We had great chemistry during those four months relationship. We were open to each other to our best. We both even shared our possessiveness with each other and we were pretty much okay too with that. We even used to talk about the little things that we don’t like about each other. We held our relationships mostly showing both our good sides as well as the bad ones too. But still that doesn’t mean in this short while we got to know everything about each other, but yet I totally believe we share great sync with each other.

    One day my parents found out about our relationship. I was hiding it from them. They were really disappointed. I belong to a very orthodox family were we strictly followed the custom of arranged marriage. In our family relationships and love marriages are a meant to be sinful. I tried my best to convince them but nothing worked. Even my boyfriend tried calling them through a phone call to introduce him and convince them. But nothing worked.

    I am the only one child for my parents and their greatest fear is that my boyfriend came into a relationship looking for any benefit. Probably for money and so on. But I clearly don’t think that because he liked me before knowing my financial status and things like that. In fact, he liked me when he first saw me in one of the college fests. He liked the way I looked, the way I talked and behaved to others. He actually proposed before we even started to become friendly. Before getting into a relationship I tried my best to know about him through our college mates. Everyone had great opinions about him and he was pretty famous and known to be a decent fellow in the college.

    Now that we broke up with a mutual understanding. We both met each other one day and I talked about my family pressures to stop our relationship. Painfully we both did that. But after having a nice conversation we made a conclusion that when both of us are settled with our studies and careers, he would talk to my parents along with his family for a marriage proposal.

    I seriously don’t know how this will work out because I don’t know how I will convince my parents at that time. I clearly don’t know how exactly I can handle this wisely.

    Right now we don’t have much contact. At times we call or text each other because we both suffered really badly after the breakup. We both went into depression for a month. We used to just call or text each other just for a push. Luckily that worked really well for both of us.

    Right now we still have a friendly relationship but yet we make a safe distance with each other.

    #278907
    treasamariam
    Participant

    can someone please reply me as soon as possible because I am in a desperate situation for a wise opinion. It will be really kind enough to help me out.

    #278919
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Naveena:

    You were friends with this young man before dating, before the two of you decided on a girlfriend/boyfriend relationship. A gf/bf relationship is considered a sin by your family.

    Since they found out about this relationship they are angry and disappointed. When your boyfriend called them to introduce himself, he made that call too late, didn’t he-

    In other words, to fit with your parents’ tradition and values, the right order of things would have been that while you and this young man were only friends and nothing else, he would have talked to his parents, then the two sets of parents would have talked about the possibility of marriage between you and this young man. Am I correct?

    anita

    #278931
    treasamariam
    Participant

    Yes, I totally agree with that. That was the biggest mistake. We didn’t have much knowledge and plannings in the initial stage of our relationship. This is the first time since we are being in a relationship ever.  He has talked this to his parents also. But according to both are parents it’s too young for us to plan about our marriages. We are still into our studies. As you know how hard this course is. Both our parents are really concerned about our studies and careers. That’s why we both came to the conclusion that we will end our relationship. A little bit of connection and contacts for now onwards, and when we both are settled with our careers, at that point in time we will make sure both our parents talk to each other. This is what we have planned for now. If then things work, only then we will move forward.

    But above all, is it something bad to be in a relationship?. Really is it sinful to love someone?

    #278937
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Naveena:

    No, it is not sinful to love someone. But unless you are okay with running away from home, eloping with him, that is you leaving your parents and home and living far away from your parents, you have to proceed wisely once you are in love.

    I was wondering: did your parents ever talk to you about what to do when you fall in love with a man, what you should do (tell them about it, I suppose, and not proceed to a girlfriend/boyfriend relationship without their knowledge)?

    The wise thing to do at this point,  assuming your parents are somewhat reasonable, is to let them know what is going on and make a plan with them, instead of making a plan without their knowledge and without them approving of your plan.

    Why don’t you choose a time when you and your parents are sitting together, calm, comfortable and tell them what you and your now friend (no longer boyfriend) want to do: to get settled with your studies and careers and after that. to ask the parents’ to arrange a marriage, ask them to consider your plan now and let you know if they agree to it?

    anita

    #278941
    treasamariam
    Participant

    I did make a conversation with them about what if I  like someone not now probably when I am around the age of marriage. And I approach them about it, before falling into a relationship. I didn’t mention about him. At first, they were little hesitated but later they were okay. The only condition was that I shouldn’t have the attitude of “I will only marry this particular guy”. They want it to be discussed together with them and fall into a final conclusion. They don’t like me taking the decision all alone because according to them as parents that’s the biggest responsibility and it is they who have to find someone for me and take the primary decision.

    To be honest, I am not stubborn that I will only tie a knot with him. I still love him a lot and care for him a lot. But right now I am keeping this aside and focus more on to my studies and career. As you mentioned earlier no matter what happens, I will never run away from my house, move away from my parents for my own pleasures. I will always make sure that my parents become comfortable too for whatever decisions I make. Just worried as to how I can convince them at that age.

     

    #278943
    treasamariam
    Participant

    My parents don’t like the concept of loving someone before marriage. I have been told, if you love someone, better forget it. That the way things are taught at home.

     

    #278947
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Naveena:

    You are not at all considering leaving your parents and you want them comfortable with you. They want to “take the primary decision” regarding your future marriage. They don’t want you to have a boyfriend. I suppose it is okay with them that you have a male friend, but not okay with you having a boyfriend except after they approve a particular man to be your husband.

    This means that you don’t have a boyfriend until your parents approve of a man to be your husband. Then maybe it will be okay with them that the approved man will be your boyfriend between the time they approve of him and the marriage.

    If I understand correctly, above, then I suggest that you have a conversation or a series of calm conversations with your parents in which you are very clear with them about you agreeing with them, that you will not have a boyfriend before and unless they approve of a man for you to marry, that at best you will get to know a man as a friend only before they meet the man. Let them know clearly that this is your plan.

    Let them know that you regret having had a boyfriend without their approval and before they met him. Tell them this will not happen again, and see to it that indeed, it doesn’t.

    Then ask them if they will be open to consider your friend (ex boyfriend) as a candidate for you in a few years, if he  settles career wise/ financially and if you and the young men will be indeed only friends between now and a few years from now.

    Do you think you can have this kind of a conversation/ conversations with them?

    anita

    #279017
    Michelle
    Participant

    But above all, is it something bad to be in a relationship?. Really is it sinful to love someone?

    It is not wrong to be in a relationship. In fact, I feel (being from the West) having relationships helps a person figure out who they are and what they want in life. Love is never sinful. Love is beautiful. Discrimination is more sinful, in my opinion. I would actually love to hear more on why your parents/culture feels love isn’t a good thing?

    I have experience in this, being a Western woman who was left by an Indian male for an arranged marriage (and thus my following statement will be biased). My advice would be that if you aren’t willing to challenge your parent’s beliefs – and the greater culture – to stand up for what you need in life, then you must accept your fate and not involve any other males who you may fall for in a romantic sense. This will take strength and a bit of defiance to cultural practices that have been set for millennia, but unless you are willing to stand up for it, it is not worth dragging the heart of an innocent person into the matter. It is not worth causing someone else pain for a matter that will never work to their favour.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.