fbpx
Menu

Is confidence a curse?

Home→Forums→Tough Times→Is confidence a curse?

New Reply
Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #41628
    Gumdrops
    Participant

    I’ve been struggling with the fact that people think I’m too ‘cocky’ as they call it, or overconfident. The worst thing is, even after much thought and discussion with my parents, I realised I’m just confident, and I believe in what I say. As head girl of my school, dealing with stuff like this is tough. I have a whole student council which needs to be satisfied to some extent. I hoped for support from the head boy, unfortunately he turned out to be someone with no stand at all, and agrees to everything everyone says. That’s all great for him, but when we’re working for a school, we need to be responsible and clear about all the decisions we make. As head of the council, do I need to become a people pleaser?
    Please help. I can’t deal with this anymore.

    #41630
    Matt
    Participant

    Gumdrops,

    There is a spectrum. If people are calling you cocky, perhaps you are not taking time to consider their views important. You say you “think you are right”, but do you give careful consideration of their views? Do you spend time researching or getting other perspectives on their concerns? You sound over confident to me, perhaps considering yourself more wise and clear seeing than you are. Even the tone of your message says “What is wrong with everyone around me, I’m of course correct and perfect, my parents agree with me.” Perhaps your parents aren’t the best ones to talk to about it, because often patterns are passed from parent to child, and you three may be too alike to provide real growth. Consider asking someone who calls you cocky to go into more detail about what they are seeing, and listen deeply to their responses.

    Leaders are not meant to take charge and make the world according to their vision. That’s what dictators do. Good leaders consider all of the people under their charge, and attempt to find a path that is compromise, co-creative, and supportive of as many people as possible. Said differently, a good leader inspires people to become better versions of themselves, growing and blooming. A poor one commands others to paint the world in her way, and steps on creativity by cutting/ignoring/invalidating others’ opinions.

    This isn’t having “no stand” but rather recognizing that a leader is a servant of the people she leads.

    With warmth,
    Matt

    #41632
    Buddhist Wife
    Participant

    I think it is a great idea to take what Matt says into consideration. It’s possible that you are just bulldozing people and that you need to be more skillfull.

    It’s difficult to know what to say because you haven’t given us many details. I’m reluctant to say more without hearing more details because depending on the culture of your school/country it’s possible that what you are experiencing is sexism. Some people do not like women to express opinions and behaviour that would be seen as confident in a man is described as arrogant in a women. However if the head boy and the council think one way and you think the other, then you are probably in the wrong. On the other hand, if the council are split and the head boy sides with one group and then with another – this presents a problem.

    #41685
    Gumdrops
    Participant

    Thank you so much 🙂 I’m working on my attitude, hopefully I’ll be able to serve my school and work together with the council!
    It definitely isn’t sexism though. I probably need to express myself better 🙂 Any suggestion for that?
    About the “no stand” thing. We both listen to everyone, it’s just that he is unable to make a decision.

    #41692
    Alexey Sunly
    Participant

    You are right, confidence is a curse 🙂 But so is infinite doubt.

    I’ve met many confident people in my life who seemed to be so sure that they know what they are doing is right only for me to realize later on that they were completely ignorant of the subject matter at hand. On the other hand, Socrates said, I know nothing. And, supposedly, he was the wisest man in Athens at the time. Because he was not willing to act upon his wisdom, he gave up and let people much more “confident” than him to prosecute and execute him for treason. He even chose to drink the poison himself, even though he had an opportunity to escape.

    Leaders must take into consideration all available to them information. Your job is to continuously seek feedback from people around you about what it is they want and need in order to compare that information with what is possible to achieve at the time. You don’t have to agree with everyone, but you need to listen to everyone, and then make a decision that works for everyone in the best way possible right now. Yes, there will always people who are disappointed with you, that’s the price of being a leader, but even they will be able to admit if you are fair to everyone. It’s a tough job, and very few people can do it well, but as long as you are willing to continuously work and learn in order to improve yourself, you will do really well 🙂

    #41704
    Matt
    Participant

    Gumdrops,

    When you asked for help in expressing yourself, I felt an image of an upward turned hand catching a ball, looking at it, then compromising or setting it down. For instance “A bikini car wash might produce some extra revenue for prom (catch), but my concern is it would sexualize the boys and girls in bikinis, which doesn’t feel right (setting it down)”. Or “I hear the concern that chips arent as healthy as carrots (catch) and wonder if we could get whole wheat chips instead (compromise)”. Often it doesn’t matter if you adopt or reject the ideas, but that you make sure you say to the person who spoke them that the ideas are being genuinely examined for merit, and whatever you find valuable in the idea is reflected back. A simple “nope” might appear that you see no value at all.

    When I ran an art studio, I often had to give artists what I referred to as a “shit sandwich”. Positive-negative-positive. Something you like, something that needs fixing, something you like.

    Good luck!

    With warmth,
    Matt

    #41728
    Gumdrops
    Participant

    Hello 🙂
    Wanted to let you guys know, I was much milder in my expression today. And I feel better already!
    Even the responses were positive. I realized the problem was people thought I was too aggressive in sharing my views. Even is they were well- informed. So I promise myself and you that I will be more accepting.
    I’m going to continue working on it, hopefully I’ll succeed.
    Thank you all so much for your replies and explanation. In fact, when I set out for school today I felt that I should come back with good news for you 🙂
    Love you all.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.