Home→Forums→Relationships→Looking for comfort and clarity on this situation
- This topic has 4 replies, 4 voices, and was last updated 2 weeks, 1 day ago by
anita.
-
AuthorPosts
-
March 10, 2025 at 10:20 am #444037
Kris
ParticipantI need to let out this and get some comfort. I started a casual sex relationship about a month ago. I am still pretty new to this, so we had our ups and downs while I figured out what I wanted or needed. I wanted more friends with benefits; he wanted a sex only thing. However, he agreed to hang out sometimes. Even for the sex thing, he was kind of flaky. Like he would say he wanted to see, but then something came up and he cancelled. He was mostly busy and had his personal things (friends, etc.) going on, which I understood because we were not dating, so I was not a priority anyway.
Finally, we were making a process, and it was beginning to be something I was enjoying. Communication was consistent (only texting for meetings, but consistent). I invited him to go to the movies. We had only hung out once before and it was for a quick lunch (the first time we met in person). When planning the movies, he said he was excited to go out with me. He said it twice that week, literally one the day before the movie. He said he may come by my place after the movies. I thought he may have some plans, so he did not want to commit. After the movies, he said that he believed he cannot come by my place, and we may have to stop seeing each other for sex. We went inside his car to talk. I asked if there was another person.
So, he said he met this woman about 1-2 years ago. They both like each other, but she never follows through plans. She lives about an hour from here. One time he agreed to meet with her in another town, he drove there (1 hr or 1 ½ hr away) and she did not show up. And it seems, she does that constantly to him. He said she has a kid, which is difficult for her (I think that if you are interested in someone, you will at least call/text him that you cannot make it). Now she is hanging out more in our town. So, she has been more consistent with him these last 2 weeks. She invited him on a trip to another State (other people are going) next month. He seemed excited about that. He said he just wanted something casual with her, but he did not want to be with both at the same time. He said they just had kissed like a year ago, that they had not sex.
He said he was open to continuing friendship with me. But I pointed out he has not been consistent with me in the past and that he was always busy. And now that she will be in his life, he will not have time to hang out with me. He said that was true, but he will have time for sure in summer because he doesn’t work.
Here is where I may overstep. I told him that if he was my friend (we were still knowing each other), I would ask him why he is still behind her if she showed him before she is inconsistent (well, that may change since she is hanging out in this town more now). I was not trying to be rude, but he did not take it well and got mad at me. He was not exactly rude, but he said that I should not use the information he gave me against him. That at least he was honest and did not ghost me (which I appreciated). He said something like the conversation was done and that I should go (leave his car). We did hug (but I don’t remember if that was before or after he told that). I think it was before he got mad because I remember I was apologizing for being rude and touching his arm. And his body language (and face) suggested to me he did not want me to touch him, and he was mad (again not rude or violent). So I don’t think he will contact me again. And I don’t think it is a good idea to contact him after that. I apologized already anyway. I don’t understand why he said he was excited about seeing me and then breaking up with me. I am guessing he may want to stay in touch with me as a friend, but the conversation did not finish as desired. I felt bad how I managed it; I should not express my opinion about the situation with the other girl.
I know I should not expect a friendship with him. I don’t even think he will be a good friend. I am madder with myself than to him. I don’t have friends or family here. I have tried, but nothing has worked out for long term. I was excited to get to know someone and hang out a few times. I felt comfortable with him having sex and I liked his company in general. My last relationship was bad, so I was trying to feel good about myself again. I am ok being alone, but it doesn’t mean I wish to have friends/partner. And then, there is the comparation with the other woman (which I know I should not). I was waiting to save some money and being better financially to move closer to my family. But after this, I think I will ask my parents for help. I still must wait for the lease to end though in September. I know I have to let this go but is difficult to do.March 10, 2025 at 12:26 pm #444042anita
ParticipantDear Kris:
Thank you for sharing your feelings— it takes strength to be so open about what you’re going through. It sounds like this situation brought up a lot of emotions, from excitement and hope to disappointment and frustration, and it’s completely valid to feel the way you do.
It seems like you were approaching this casual relationship with good intentions, looking for both intimacy and a connection, but it’s hard when the other person’s actions don’t match what you were hoping for. It sounds like he’s conflicted about what he wants, but his actions—like being flaky and now focusing on someone else— haven’t aligned with the consistency you deserve.
I also think you’re being too hard on yourself about how the last conversation went. You were just being honest, and it’s not wrong to share your perspective, even if he didn’t take it well. It’s natural to feel disappointed or frustrated in that moment, especially when you’ve been open and understanding with him.
It also sounds like there’s a deeper challenge here— feeling isolated without friends or family close by. That loneliness can make situations like this feel even heavier. I think moving closer to your family, as you mentioned, could be a great step toward building the support system you need. In the meantime, maybe exploring local groups, hobbies, or events could help you meet new people and create a sense of community.
This experience may feel overwhelming right now, but you’ve shown a lot of self-awareness and emotional strength in reflecting on it. Be kind to yourself as you process everything, and remember this situation doesn’t define you or your worth.
If you ever need to talk, I’m here to listen. You’re not alone.
anita
March 11, 2025 at 10:34 am #444070Roberta
ParticipantDear Kris
I am sorry that things did not work out for you in the way you had hoped.
I know that “friends with benefits ” is trendy – as is hook ups which is the modern equivalent of one night stands for my younger years.
I agree with Anita’s advice about how to find & make friends in your area. If you are also wishing to fulfill your sexual desires, then a vibrator wont stand you up & also there is no chance of getting an STI.
I hope that you find a worthwhile relationships both inside & out of the bedroom. Honor & respect your needs in a way that does not cause you harm. Many of us have been thru this dilemma – forty years on I still cringe or laugh at some of my escapades.
kind regards
RobertaMarch 11, 2025 at 1:34 pm #444073Alessa
ParticipantHi Kris
It is a shame to hear that things ended with your friends with benefits person. It is hard especially when you don’t have anyone that you are close to locally.
I agree that you didn’t do anything wrong. It is a question that a friend would ask with his best interest at heart. I feel like he might not actually be looking for a friend. Unfortunately, sometimes people just say these things when they part ways with no real intention of friendship or even keeping in touch.
It is okay to feel your feelings about all of this. Please take extra special care of yourself while things are tough. ❤️
It sounds like a good idea to move back to somewhere you have a bit more support. I hope that your parents can help you with this and the time flies by until your lease is up in September.
March 12, 2025 at 11:27 am #444090anita
ParticipantDear Kris:
Your thread inspired me to explore the topic of friends with benefits (FWB) further. I’d love to hear your thoughts on the brief research I’ve compiled below, and I hope it might offer some help as you seek comfort and clarity on this situation (referencing the title of your thread, “Looking for comfort and clarity on this situation”):
Historically, casual sexual relationships have existed in various forms, but the term “friends with benefits” gained popularity in the late 20th century, particularly with the rise of dating apps and media portrayals. Wikipedia in its entry on the topic says that the earliest known use of the term was in the 1995 song “Head Over feet” where one of the lines is: “you’re my best friend, best friend with benefits.”
FWB relationships are typically ongoing arrangements between friends who engage in intimacy without committing to a romantic relationship. While some FWB arrangements might evolve into traditional romantic relationships, this isn’t a defining feature— it depends entirely on the individuals involved and their mutual feelings over time.
One-night stands and hookups, on the other hand, are usually short-term, often one-time encounters with no expectation of an ongoing connection, let alone a romantic relationship. They’re more about spontaneity and physical attraction than emotional or relational depth.
From psypost. org/ longitudinal-study-suggests-friends-with-benefits-relationships-work-out-best-for-those-hoping-to-transition-to-friendship: “An online survey was completed by 192 people currently in a friends with benefits relationship (FWBR). All subjects were assessed during an initial survey where they were asked certain things about their FWBR, including how they hoped the relationship would evolve — into friendship, into a romantic relationship, dissipate altogether, or stay the same.
“Most subjects (48%) hoped their FWBR would stay the same, while a quarter of them (25%) hoped that it would turn into a romantic relationship. Smaller numbers of people wanted it to transition to a regular friendship free of sex (12%) or no relationship at all (4%).
“Around 10 months later, subjects took part in a follow-up survey where they were questioned on how their FWBR had evolved… Those who were the least likely to see the relationship outcome they wanted were those who had said they wanted it to transition into romance — only 15% of those who wanted romance saw it happen…
“A reported lack of communication between partners was related to an increased likelihood of the relationship dissipating altogether, suggesting that if partners want to stay in any kind of relationship at all, communication is crucial. ‘Whereas communication is important to all relationship outcomes, it is likely even more important than in traditional romantic relationships,’ the authors emphasize, ‘because FWBRs lack a guiding cultural script to define the roles and trajectory… Machia and colleagues conclude that both communication and aligned expectations are critical for an FWBR to end well.”
anita
-
AuthorPosts