fbpx
Menu

Sister in Law hates me!

HomeForumsRelationshipsSister in Law hates me!

New Reply
Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #74395
    Saoirse
    Participant

    I am in the happiest relationship of my life with an amazing and kind man. He has a sister who is very close in age to him. I got the impression that they were extremely close from the word go, however as I began to spend more time with him I began to realize that she was extremely controlling of him, demanding favors and getting very verbally aggressive if he did not oblige. As he began to spend more time with me, I could sense tension and when I met her she did not seem overly friendly, and has never seemed this way to me since. She would not acknowledge our relationship on social network sites, and even when we moved in together recently the decision was met by criticism by her. This week I was out with my boyfriend and he received a call from her, shouting and verbally abusing me because of a casual joking comment I made to a friend on a social network site about a particular mall we were in, mentioning that we had seen 2 incidents of crime in 30 mins. The mall itself was in the same neighbourhood that both my boyfriend and his sister grew up in. She took my comment as a personal insult and claimed I was disrespecting them and their family. She then insulted the neighborhood that I am from. I asked to speak to her myself and she refused. She also went straight to her parents and exaggerated the story to them which greatly upset me as I care hugely about my boyfriends parents and their opinions of me. I do not like to have anger and bitterness in my life so I asked to speak to her a number of times during the day, to which she refused or hung up on me. Since then there has been no contact and I feel like this is a weight around my neck. I personally feel that she has had a problem with me from Day 1 due to jealousy, but I would be interested to see how others feel. My boyfriend is totally ashamed of her and is very angry with her also. I don’t want this to affect our relationship and we are both trying to get on with our lives, but I feel like I cannot relax until I speak to her directly and air my grievances with her. She will always be a part of our lives and no way do I want a rift created in the family, but I am unsure what way to handle this. I do not enjoy fighting with anyone and it would be an extreme rarity that I would ever argue with my family or friends. I feel like this situation is out of my control. Please help!

    #74408
    Inky
    Participant

    Don’t be on audition for people who already don’t like you. Which means don’t talk to her. Why bother?

    When she met you (and it could have been anyone), she knew that the party’s over concerning her brother. I doubt any other person in her life would allow her to treat them that way, so of course all her ire is taken out on you. And guess what, her parents already know that that is how she is. If she took offence at what some passing joking comment online, she would take offence at anything.

    What you do is see the family on holidays. Be super polite to her, no matter what she says or does. Then you will have done “your part”. She won’t do hers, but everyone knows that already. No worries.

    #74415
    Saoirse
    Participant

    Thank you for taking the time to reply to this Inky. I agree with you in that her problem may not even be personal, rather that I have taken her brother away. I suppose that I am conflicted in that I don’t want her to think I am a pushover and that I accept the fact that she has said horrible things about me, as I do not accept this treatment. I believe in sorting things directly with the person and its frustrating for me that she is not allowing that to happen. I am so unused to having bad feeling like this hang over me. Your kind advice has helped me see it all from a different point of view. I need not to worry so much!

    #74487
    Corina
    Participant

    Sad to say that I dont like my brother’s new wife my sister in law.
    She hasnt even been in the family for over 1.5 years and already created some drama.
    I think she brain washes my brother because things are not the same anymore.
    So sweet but inside she is so insecure and judgemental.
    I love God and the bible but this woman is really religious that she even creates rules and doesn’t care if it hurts family memebers like my fiance and i live together we already have a date for the wedding and booked vendors (yay) lol. but she and my OWN brother will not visit because we are not married. GET OFF YOUR FK HIGH HORSE! And other stuff to. How her and my brother pressued me to take a “family” photo in their lame wedding with the person who abused me when i was a child. Yes of course they still talk to the monster like nothing is wrong but if i say anything ? i am a selfish brat…figures so i dont have relationship with them 2 at all and i dont think i ever will be.
    they are having a kid soon so….am i that evil to say i dont care about that either? I wish i did care but i just dont..to many painful stories…cant wait to get the fk out of here after the wedding on my honey with my lovely soon to be husband and just leave phones here while vacationing no one ANNOYING us
    sorry this topic made me think about my sister in law. >=(

    #74754
    Jes
    Participant

    My potential sister in law is somewhat the same as this. But she is very quiet about how she continuously makes my life difficult. My boyfriend’s mother and father have invited my family around at the weekend to spend some time at their house in Essex and given the opportunity, we took up the offer due to the fact that i live in the West Midlands.
    I only found out that my boyfriend’s sister was not going to be present at the FIRST family get together because she wants to revise for an exam she has in 2 weeks.
    I was angry and upset that she wasn’t making the effort with me or my family and that she had used a lame excuse to get out of this family get together.

    After a while though, i realised that only getting myself down about it is only going to hurt me even more inside. I knew that i had made many efforts with her in the past and none of them had been acknowledged by her or her parents but i decided that i wasn’t going to be sad about it anymore.

    My advise to Saoirse, is to just hold your head up high and carry on being happy with every intention and thought of happiness in your body.

    My 3 tips to follow are:
    1.) Speak when you are spoken to.
    – the best thing to do is just be quiet and listen to your surroundings. Embrace the world you are in and look at all the natural things that bring you make down to earth again. When someone asks you a question, answer it and then resume with looking around. Simple.

    2.) Don’t get angry.
    – As the timeless Disney (and very annoying) song goes, ‘Let it go!’ If you hold it with you for days and nights, you’re only hurting yourself. Don’t let negativity like that get the better of you. You are in charge of you and you can control your thoughts to be positive, happy and free.

    3.) Read books and talk about your emotions on a regular basis.
    – This one is a bit far-fetched but if you talk about your problems with a close friend or boyfriend you will feel like you can finally be at peace once its out. The most important part after you do this is DON’T GET YOUR ANGER GET THE BETTER OF YOU. Consider this to be the last thing you do before closing the case and not mentioning it again.
    Books are a really good way to get into the spiritual side of feeling better about yourself. My most recent read was a book by one of my favourite people in the world – Thich Nhat Hanh. (He is really good at making you feel better about yourself and not getting angry about insignificant others that try to get you down!)

    Practice self-control. Be witty but not rude and don’t let it get you down.

    #75000
    Saoirse
    Participant

    Thank you PeaceLoveJes for taking the time to give me your advice. It is now nearly 3 weeks and neither of us has heard from her, but this has resulted in my having no choice but to try let the situation go. I suppose the fact that I have not had the opportunity to speak to her (not by choice) has allowed my anger to subside a bit and see the bigger picture.
    I agree that letting your anger get the better of you does you no good, and you only hurt yourself by holding resentment.
    I will research Thich Nhat Hanh’s books, as I (and my boyfriend) believe it is important to live a peaceful life. I am very thankful that all of my immediate relationships are happy and peaceful and maybe this incident made me appreciate that more. It worries me that unfortunately I will have to see her at future events, including an upcoming wedding, but I suppose the advantage I have is that her parents are totally aware of the situation and that I did nothing wrong, and have been nothing but accepting to me. And I know that worrying will never change any situation’s outcome.

    #75179
    Jes
    Participant

    Hey!

    You’re very welcome! I’m so glad that her parents can see that you have done nothing wrong. It’s not quite like that with my situation – My boyfriend’s parents come down like a tonne of bricks on him but let his sister get away with a lot of things.
    Its really refreshing to hear that they are on your side! (I hope one day his parents will be on my side too!)

    I have steered my boyfriend over to a more spiritual way of thinking recently, after reading Thich Nhat Hanh books and being the amazing person he is, he has fully embraced my Buddhist family background and hopped on the bandwagon.

    I have to see my future sister-in-law pretty much every fortnight, but i have stopped texting her to ask how she is now, as i used to do it frequently and get one word answers. I have taken the opportunity to go to a hen-do of our future cousin AND share a room with her mom AND her! BIG STEPS!
    I know its going to be difficult and i’m very sure she doesn’t like being around me, but I have made the effort to be around her, so i will just be myself, but try to remember the things i have read in books to help me get through the hen-do weekend.

    I am worried too, that i have to see her; watch her pull funny faces at my jokes, roll her eyes, and not even look at me when i’m trying to talk to her. But i’ve accepted that she is her own person and if thats the way she is, then so be it. Like you said, worrying isn’t going to help the situation or you.

    Will definitely give you an update on the hen-do weekend scheduled at the end of next month. And on any mindful thinking that helped me get through it 🙂

    #75572
    Saoirse
    Participant

    Hi Jes,

    I suppose we are both very lucky that in both our cases our boyfriends are fully devoted to us and don’t let their sisters come between us. To hear that she rolls her eyes and pulls funny faces is upsetting, but I guess I have learned in the past while and from helpful advice from yourself and others, that this is all an exercise in being mindful, appreciating what we have and living a positive life no matter what the circumstance.

    My sister in law sent my boyfriend a text out of the blue at the weekend, acting like nothing was wrong. This caused friction as I allowed myself to get annoyed that she had the cheek to expect him to act normal towards her (like he would have done when she bullied him before we were together.) He asked to meet her to talk things through, this brief meeting didnt have a totally positive outcome but she admitted she didnt like that I was taking him away from her. I appreciate that he had the courage to stand up to his lifelong bully, and have been trying my best (again!!) to not let her bitterness affect my mood.

    Its extremely difficult to know that she will always be lingering in the background. I hope that the hen-do goes well and that the effort you made to be positive and also the bigger person, pays off. I know nobody would expect that girl to do a total 360 but I guess we can only control how we react to people’s actions, and not their actions themselves. xx

    #75954
    Jes
    Participant

    Hey Saoirse!

    I just wanted to message back to ask how things have been with your sister-in-law and boyfriend since we last spoke?
    Any news or contact with her?

    And what has happened following the meeting she and your boyfriend had, after she admitted her insecurities?

    Mostly, i am hoping you are alright and that your techniques and strategies to deal with this conflict, are getting stronger.
    I really hope you are finding a way to feel peace inside 🙂

    x

    #76026
    Saoirse
    Participant

    Hi Jes,

    Thank you so much for checking in with me! 🙂 Following the last meeting there was not much change, no major contact/outreaching from her. My boyfriend requested another meeting with her to discuss her outburst against me, where again she remained negative, turning every question back on him and criticising him, down to the way he looked!! He said he asked her out straight what her problem was with me and she could not give any fair or reasonable straight answer. It again did not really end with any conclusion. He met his Dad after who advised him to stop trying to ask her to change or get an apology from her, that it wont happen, that he needs to concentrate on his life and his relationship with me and our future. It was refreshing to hear his father’s point of view. I guess we both learned from this advice to stop trying to seek closure from her, rather to attain peace through ourselves and our relationship together. Its definately a new experience for me, as I always would have seeked closure directly from the person that there was an issue with (which in itself was rare as I do not come across many instinces of conflict in my day to day life.)

    I guess we both realise that she wont change, she wont do what we seek and apologise for her actions. I do in a way feel like realising this has almost lifted a weight from me, stupid as it sounds. We wont let her cause conflict between us or seep into our happiness like poison. I’m happy that my relationship with his parents is good and his with my family is great also. I’m also thankful that he wont listen to her negativity and sees me for the person I am, and not the person she would like me to be!!

    I hope you are keeping well and living in harmony, besides having the burden of a negative sister in law also! xx

    #76075
    Jes
    Participant

    hey! In a way, I’m glad she hasn’t reached out to you after the heated discussion. She seems like a very insecure person; belittling her own brother and even being as shallow as pointing out how he looks. And because she couldn’t give her brother a reason as to why she didn’t like you, I genuinely think she’s just nit-picking at immature things, which is really sad.

    I’m glad your boyfriend went to talk to his dad (your father-in-law), because i often do this too with my mother. I’m always telling her about how much my sister-in-law is emotionally hurting me. And the best part is, that your father-in-law and my mother both have said the same thing – Stop asking, stop trying to change the way she is and concentrate on the relationship you have with your other half. My mother always says; “You are marrying your boyfriend, not his parents or siblings.” And that is what i always remind myself when times get hard.

    In the past 3 months, I have lost 2 of my Uncles on both my mother’s and father’s side of my family so things here have been horrible for all of us. My mother and father-in-law, phoned my parents to offer their condolences and my boyfriend came to visit the family almost immediately after he heard the news.
    I text my sister-in-law about 2 days ago, asking how she was, how her holiday was with her partner (and he had fallen ill with food poisoning), so i asked if he was feeling better. At first, she read my messages, but didn’t reply. Then the next day, she text me back saying she had forgotten to text me – which i was fine with.
    She asked how i was, to which i said things were getting better around here but its very difficult. At this point, she went quiet.
    Then she said, “Oh my brother’s only just told me about your Uncle. Sorry about that.” I changed the subject very quickly but i was angry.
    I was so angry that my boyfriend didn’t tell her and nobody in his family (cousins, aunties, uncles) offered their condolences at the time. Not even my sister-in-law.
    My sister who is recently and happily married told her in-laws and all her husband’s family, and they were at my house almost everyday after we got the bad news.

    I finally understand, that some people, you will never be able to change, and accepting them for who they are is hard… but you have to do it. After acceptance, you can finally start to live life in peace.
    I’m happy that you have chosen this route too and that things are looking up for you and your boyfriend.
    I’m happy too. Difficult times only make a person stronger!

    Btw, how do you pronounce your name? (There was an Irish girl at school, who had the same name as you but i never spoke to her because i couldn’t say her name!)
    xo

    #77049
    Saoirse
    Participant

    Hi, I’m so sorry to hear about your loss, I hope that the pain will ease for your family over time. Its tragedies like that that really help put things into perspective! I’ve still had zero contact with the sister, and neither has my boyfriend. I suppose the only issue now is that there is a family wedding in August where obviously she will be there. Its strange because i always presumed I would never let anyone make me feel like this, I’m very straight up when ever i have an issue with someone. (I dont really take offence easily so this would be rare anyway.) I’m trying not to worry about the situation too much and just deal with things as they come. It can be difficult though. Its all about practising self belief and trying to ease your worrying I guess.

    The name is pronounced “Seer-sha” its Gaelic for peace. 🙂 xx

    #77069
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Saorise:
    Your original account of how you made a joke about the mall being unsafe and your sister in law claiming angrily that you offended her and her family and did it intentionally and proceeded with attacking you… I am very familiar with this kind of behavior. My own mother often took something innocent I said (or did not say… but should have said, according to her), did (or did not do but should have done..)… even an expression on my face and claimed that I was hurting her and that I intended to hurt her. Trying to defend myself against her UNTRUE accusations did nothing. She only increased her attack of me. She felt justified in attacking me, claiming I was making her hit me, that she was only REACTING to my alleged attack on her. It was a horrible way of “growing in” as I call it and had a hugely detrimental effect on five decades of my life. It is only in the last few years, beginning with my first effective experience at psychotheraly that I started to heal. It was a horrible experience to be attacked over anything at all, attacks i was not able to prevent or to stop. These people, these bullies- I finally cut contact with my mother- oh, did i mention, cutting all contact with her was necessary for my healing which is still in progress. Some people are poison. Their MO is to ATTACK any which way. How do you “get along” with an attacker who NEEDS to hurt you? You get away. I hope your sister in law doesn’t have children or that she doesn’t attack them, take an exception with them. If you have comments on my story, Saoirse, or any of the commentators here, please do comment.
    Take Care:
    anita

    #211977
    Sherly
    Participant

    My sister-in-law already hates me and has sent me vulgar messages to stop our relationship the day that she found out me and my boyfriend travel together without getting married but I didn’t because he is a really nice guy and we don’t have any conflicts between each other. His parents kind of like me and get along quite well with me. She made a big drama when they came to visit my parents for the first time for lunch even in front of her parents, and my parents were really upset about the situation because it was a very disrespectful behaviour. She was looking at her phone the whole time making faces and never spoke to me or anyone and it was very obvious that she is pissed and upset. And everyone felt so uncomfortable and they even left early right after lunch. She is so spoilt, entitled and bossy and has conservative thinking.

    The problem is my in-laws don’t admit that her behaviour is unacceptable they think she is still young and that’s because she loves her brother. Things are getting tougher as we are planning to get married this December. I am a Buddhist and my Boyfriend is a Catholic. At first, they asked me to convert to a Catholic saying that it is not good to receive the full wedding mass at the Church. And I unwillingly agreed because I simply didn’t want to make an issue. And I agreed to take her as one of my bride’s maids although she has never spoken to me yet. Both I and my boyfriend thought she will be alright after a while but her attitude has never changed. Her parents always defend her and once asked me not to take bridesmaids at all for the weeing because they are not sure if she will get along with my relations during the wedding, but I really want to take my best friends as my maids. I’m really scared to take her because of her attitude, she really hates me and I hate her 100 times more, but I always smile and keep quiet because I don’t want to create an ugly situation.

    How do I go about this? Should I keep quiet and take her as the bridesmaid? Please help me if anyone has a solution or any opinion.

    Thank you so much!

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.