Menu

My Boyfriends Female Friend makes me uncomfortable…

Home→Forums→Relationships→My Boyfriends Female Friend makes me uncomfortable…

New Reply
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 18 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #461750
    Olive
    Participant

    My boyfriend’s female friend makes me uncomfortable

    I know, I’ve heard this one a thousand times, and I know what I’d probably advise to my friends, but it’s difficult to think lucidly from inside.

    Some background –
    I’ve been with “Sam” for a year. He’s had his friend “Jane” since they were in school, probably 10 years. I don’t have that kind of bond, so maybe that’s why I’m struggling to relate or rationalise the circumstances.

    My longest friendship is 7 years with another woman, and we’ve been through a lot, travelled together, lived together, and know everything about each other, but I still him its different- we met while working overseas, we didn’t grow up together, our parents don’t all know eachother, we didn’t go to school together, etc.

    There’s also male friends “Ken” , “Nate”, and “Marv”.

    I recently moved in with S and his parents in a small town, which is undoubtedly contributing to my feelings of isolation and anxiety, as the relationship moves fast, I wasn’t planning to move here, and now I’m struggling to find a job. I’ve struggled all my life with depression and recently it’s reared it’s head again.

    Everyone is about 26-27, whereas I am 30.

    This is my first and longest real relationship. My previous relationships (3+ YEARS AGO) were abusive, I was physically and emotionally harmed, and also cheated on – which I can conceive affecting my judgement, and I try to be thoughtful and sit with my emotions and understand whether the source of feeling triggered comes from within, my past experience and scars, or comes from present inappropriate behaviour….

    But I’m struggling. I can’t reach out to my best friend for insight or advice right now as it would be unfair to burden her in her current circumstances.

    I found this website and am very eager to hear anyone’s thoughts – I would be grateful for someone willing to take the time to read through my situation and share their opinions/ wisdom, as I feel like my emotions are clouded now.

    Based on what I’ve shared so far, I know I am the odd one out, and I feel like it. Along with my history, I take it into account and am reluctant to bring up my discomfort with my boyfriend, as I know it’s possible I could be making an issue out of nothing, or getting myself upset.

    Regarding Jane, I met her almost 10 months ago the first time I visited this town. I think she’s sweet, emotionally intelligent and caring. She’s the only one in the friend group with a license and is relied upon for travel and group excursions a lot of the time. I like her and I want to like her but there are some things that have triggered alarm bells ;

    – either the first or second time I met her, there was a conversation between her and Ken in which she boasted about her manipulation skills, and recalled an occasion where she won a game against him by pretending to cry.
    – the second or third time I met her, it was Myself, Sam, Jane and Nate walking home, we sat down for a moment and she brought up out of nowhere that her mom thinks Jane and Sam should be together. This made me very uncomfortable, and I felt like saying that was very strange, and crossed a boundary, but Sam Nate and I just didn’t really react. She followed up with saying that would be gross, like incest.
    However she has brought this up again on another occasion when we were at her house playing board games.
    – she talks quite matter-of-factly about her dating life / sexual health. I generally appreciate when women are so comfortable doing that as I am more reserved, but it sometimes makes me uncomfortable, but I think it’s normal
    – Nate and Ken both apparently have feelings for her , but we all continue to hang out as a group, without new boundaries – I’m not trying to say she’s leading them on or aiming to make an accusation, but I do get a sense she enjoys it, as there was a time she was discussing Ken , and stated offhand ‘everyone knows he’s in love with me’ which struck me as odd.
    – Jane has been planning to move East to the city in November (Our friend Marv is moving with her). In June she got a weekend job at the bar my boyfriend works at . She already had two decent paying jobs and has never worked in a bar, but I understand she wanted a little extra cash, and to get some experience in hospitality as it’s easier to find work in bars in the city. But it made me uncomfortable, it’s a very small bar , they were in very close quarters, and she started wearing more revealing clothes , that everyone noticed and commented on – which sidenote she should be allowed to do without anyone commenting and I’m angry on her behalf that she received any feedback like that, but I’m a hypocrite because it still worries me. I’ve worked in bars, I know what it’s like. I know that being a woman behind the bar draws attention no matter what you wear, I know when you pass by in a narrow space there’s often unintended physical touch, often it’s intended. I’m trying not to think the worst of either of them, but I also feel stupid not to recognise what happens working in a bar, after working 10 years in bars.
    – I dropped my boyfriend off at a shift they both worked and he asked what I was going to do while he was at work , she said ” you could move out while he’s at work”. I was stunned but didn’t show any reaction and just laughed and said ” yeah I could, but I’m not going to”. But that’s a bizarre thing to say right? Am I going insane ?

    Another thing worth noting is I’ve never asked Sam if they’ve previously been in a relationship. I would like to think that wouldn’t matter, what matters it present behaviour. But maybe I’m also afraid of knowing, as it would give substance to what I’m seeing now.

    I am worried that whatever I say to my boyfriend would then be mentioned to Jane, and I don’t want her to know she’s getting to me if that’s what she’s trying to do, create drama or whatever. But I’m uncomfortable holding this suspicious attitude! However it’s the reality that has developed over the months of knowing her.

    There is some behaviour from Sam that bothers me, but again, I also don’t want to get worked up and bring it up if I’m really just overanalyzing, and he’s only exhibiting normal behaviour between friends / sisterly affection. I don’t want to upset him and I don’t want to make a big deal, especially if she’s leaving in a few weeks anyway.

    It is as follows :

    – I feel sidelined when she’s around, like he doesn’t hear me / ignores me, but this is true in some other circumstances and I have mentioned it too him with the context of “when we’re in groups I feel left out” or “when he’s at work I sometimes feel cut off or ignored but understand that he’s working and customer service and the running of the bar is the priority then, not me”, not with the context of Jane being the key figure in these scenarios
    – I haven’t mentioned this but he seems to subconsciously cut me off from the group circle if we’re just stood chatting, standing slightly in front of me instead of stepping back and allowing space for me to stand , which I get if he’s used to just standing with his friends but it stings and we’ve been together for long enough now that I want to feel included too
    – this feels so petty to even write down but he sits next to her in the passenger seat instead of with me in the back even when there’s four of us and the fourth person could be in the passenger seat
    – When we walk outside he appears to instinctively walk up close to her with no space for me to be next to him, and sometimes I feel like I’m just alone in the back forgotten.
    – He’ll answer her phone calls when we’re in the middle of a conversation, just suddenly be in a different conversation on the phone and leave me feeling cut off. Then when he’s done he’ll resume with “sorry , you were saying?” And it feels rude and disregarding
    – Sometimes my boyfriend does a sort of play fight dynamic with Jane, and I know that happens with friends , male and female, I’ve roughhoused with my male friends. Honestly I think I am projecting with this one but it’s beginning to feel flirtatious on some plane, or at least I feel like it’s suggesting flirtation to Jane, like little boys being mean to the one they like. When we were out as a group recently, Sam was playing pool with Marv and I was sat with Jane, he came over and booped her on the forehead but then gave me the middle finger. Sometimes we have a joking sort of aggression too but that really struck me and hurt my feelings so much that I had to leave.

    I don’t want this all to bother me, but I don’t think I can justify it forever as ignorance or naivete, I don’t know what’s going on!

    Jane studied psychology at university, she bragged about being manipulative, and she doesn’t drink so I know she’s switched in and could have the capacity to behave in a calculated way.

    I don’t want to become suspicious and paranoid, but I am undeniably uncomfortable.

    Today I’ve been feeling very upset about it all, but don’t know whether I should bring it up with Sam , or just wait a few more weeks for her to move to the city , and hope that the distance makes it easier for me to think objectively. She will be back to visit for Christmas , and I want to do what I can to remove any weird feelings from my part so I can make an effort to be friends.

    Can anyone offer any impartial insight that can help me work through my feelings and decide where to start a conversation with my boyfriend? Am I the problem? My inner wounds?

    I feel like I’m getting lost and clouded from doubting my instincts, justifying everything, then re analyzing everything, then just becoming numb. I just want to let this all go and not worry about her, but I would never take steps to cut her off as I don’t want my boyfriend to lose a close friend. The other option would be to break up and I don’t want that either.

    If my post is confusing, I am sorry. I feel like my thoughts are very tangled and I hope anyone can offer some advice for thinking more clearly about this.

    Final note- I am planning to seek a therapist once I can secure a job, LOL!

    Thank you,

    Olive

    #461756
    anita
    Participant

    Hello Olive! Just wanted to say that I read only a bit of your post and am looking forward to read all of it and reply this evening (it’s 2 pm here).

    #461757
    anita
    Participant

    Hello again, Olive 🙂

    I read your whole post, but honestly, I am not intelligent enough (I mean it) to process it on a first (or a 2nd or 3rd 😑) reading. So, bear with me as I re-read it, respond to this or that part, read more, respond and so on. It will take some time and a few replies.

    So, Sam and Jane have known each other since high school, both were 16 or 17 and living in a small town. Both are now 26 or 27.

    You met Sam overseas a year ago, and recently moved with him to his small town, living with his parents and socializing with his high school friends: Ken, Nate, Marv and Jane. You have no friends of your own there, unemployed, and feeling isolated and a bit depressed

    You are 30, and this 1-year relationship is your longest “real relationship”. In your previous relationship, more than 3 years ago, you were abused physically and emotionally, as well as having been cheated on.

    As I read the different things Jane said at different times, I figured she feels very comfortable to say whatever is on her mind at any time, nothing malicious.. just talking too much.

    When I read that she said that maybe you should move out (when you dropped Sam at the bar where both work), I was puzzled. It sounds like, maybe Sam told Jane (not in your presence) that you disapproved of the two of them working together.. and that’s what she responded to,

    Or he didn’t tell her any such thing, and she thought it on her own and said it, because she doesn’t pause and think something like: ‘I thought it, but maybe I shouldn’t say it’

    She blurts things out.

    You wrote that you never asked Sam if he was in a relationship with Jane. From my understanding at this point, if they were in a relationship, you would have heard it from Jane, and very early on, I think..

    I’ll process the rest of your message later.

    🤔 Anita

    #461761
    anita
    Participant

    I have a better idea, Olive: can you tell me what you think of what I wrote above?

    I’ll continue- and adjust my understanding- after receiving your reply.

    🙂 Anita

    #461768
    Roberta
    Participant

    Dear Olive

    I have just read your post, I hear & understand your pain in the way that your bf physical actions, ie taking the phone call, his bodily positioning in the group circle & sitting in the passenger seat instead of in the back with you. It could just be habit, has he had
    girlfriends in the past, & how had they been integrated into that long standing friends group?
    It appears that Jane has been the Alpha female in that friendship group & probably in other situations as well. Are there any other females that a part of the group?
    I hope that once she spreads her wings, that will ease some of your concerns, then if some of your bf habits still bothersome, they could be pointed out gently using NVC. My partner had been a lay practioner living at the monastery & when we went back for a visit we met up with another woman friend of his. He didnot introduce me as his girlfriend, so she was all over him like a rash, when I pointed out to him how flirty she was with him & that he had sidelined me, he was clueless. We had a discussion about how we wanted to be introduced/ addressed in future, as we were in our 50’s boyfriend/girlfriend did not fit , partner could just be interpreted as business partners, we settled on – this is my beloved or sometimes best beloved.

    I am sure that Anita will walk you thru the many different aspects of your post.
    I hope that you quickly get a job & start to find your feet & joy in your new location.
    Best wishes
    Roberta

    #461772
    Arnz
    Participant

    Hey Olive, ouch I totally understand why this would hurt! I think if only a few of these things you’ve mentioned were going on, then it’s understandable to be a bit frustrated but let it ‘slide’, but as you’ve noticed a lot of things on several occasions, I think you have a right to ask and tell Sam whatever is on your mind, and he – as your boyfriend – should honour your wish to not feed this back to Jane. If you tell him you want to keep the convo between you and him and not tell Jane, and he proceeds to tell Jane, then that’d be disrespectful. Apologies I don’t have much more advice to give but I think if you and Sam are bf and gf then it makes sense to be free to share what’s on your mind 🙂

    I had a similar situation only this week with someone who was close to me. There were so many things that bothered me about our dynamic but I let it go unspoken for too long that I got exhausted and had to let it go. I wouldn’t want this to happen to you and Sam, so it’s better to mention it. Write it all down first on paper to get it out of your head then schedule a time to talk about it with him.

    To help put your mind at rest, your observations are normal and totally worth mentioning! I think our subconscious is a lot more clever at reading signals than we give it credit for. All the best! Arnz

    #461773
    anita
    Participant

    Good Friday morning (here), Olive:

    I neglected to say it yesterday, so I’ll say it today:

    Welcome to the Forums, Olive 🫶

    Earlier this morning, before I went online, several things ocurred to me:

    1) You wrote about exchanges involving Sam, Jane and you, but nothing involving you and Sam alone, about what’s happening in private between the two of you.

    2) Unlike Jane who says anything and everything she feels like saying (seems to me), you keep everything inside, and say very little.

    3) Even though you say very little about how you feel, I’m guessing that your understandable disatisfaction with the situation shows on your face and in your very silence.

    Jane’s comment about you moving out and Sam giving you the middle finger at that one incident, may be reactions to what they’re thinking you’re thinking, but not saying.

    4) You moved to his small town, living with him and his parents. You didn’t mention your own family or anything valuable that you left behind so to move to his small town.

    Perhaps he was the best or only support you had at the time, or perhaps he was your hope for support that you didn’t have where you were at the time?

    Overall, you are indeed sidelined in the interactions you described, and I’m so sorry that this is the situation. I know only too well how it feels 😔

    Question: is it because they (Sam, Jane) are immature and insensitive, and/ or is it because they assume negative things about you that aren’t true simply because you don’t express yourself vocally and directly to them as you did here, in your thread?

    There’s more that you shared that I didn’t respond to, but I would very much like to read your responses to my replies, as well as to Roberta’s and Amz’s, so to keep talking and learning, in hope it’ll help.

    🤍 Anita

    #461793
    Olive
    Participant

    Good morning Roberta,

    Thank you for reading my post and taking the time to reply. I appreciate your well wishes. I think you could be right about habit, and the alpha dynamic, as there are no other women in the group. I’m sorry to hear the trouble you had, but please to hear you worked it out with your beloved.

    Perhaps my boyfriend also doesn’t realise Jane’s flirtations, and is just used to her being touchy, or maybe its innocuous and she’s just physically affectionate, holding him and touching him when she laughs all the time seems flirtatious to me, but perhaps she’s just flirtatious and doesn’t have boundaries. It bothered me a few weeks ago when she was bragging to her manager in front of me about Sam falling asleep on her shoulder during a train ride the two of them took home alone together from the city earlier this year. HE never mentioned it, so maybe in his eyes it was innocent and meaningless. but hearing it made me feel really uncomfortable.

    I don’t know. I think based of your experience, I should probably just ask Sam about it and see his perspective, and work from there, my fear is creating tension or issues when it may all resolve with her leaving, although I guess I already bear the tension alone.

    I appreciate your feedback! It has given me some more perspective, and I thank you

    #461794
    Olive
    Participant

    Arnz, thank you for your empathy, I think you’re right, I shouldn’t be scared to share what’s on my mind with my boyfriend, I fear I’m just affected by past experiences, and being dismissed or manipulated as I know I can be naive, but I know he’s not like that. I will take your advice to write things down and plan a talk when I’m ready.

    I am struggling with my observations, and how to judge them objectively without being overly suspicious and biased from my past wounds, and without being too naive and ignorant. I am getting overwhelmed with the back and forth and unable to find balance yet, so I am getting exhausted, and you’re right, instead of keeping it bottled up I should probably act before I reach my limit.

    Thank you

    #461795
    Olive
    Participant

    This reply has been reported for inappropriate content.

    Good Saturday morning Anita (about 11:30 here),

    Thank you for your warm welcome to the forum, for taking the time to read my post and for your thoughtful responses. I’m sorry I didn’t respond sooner as my post went to be moderated before publishing and I wasn’t sure how long that would take, so I didn’t check back until now !

    I’m sorry that the post was confusing, thank you for your effort to read and understand it, I suppose it relays how confused I am feeling inside. My thought’s are very overwhelming and its difficult to organise them clearly.

    Regarding your first response on Thursday evening, I think you could be right, that there’s nothing malicious in Jane’s actions, and going from what Roberta inferred too, she may just be used to being the only woman around in the group, and very comfortable just saying whatever she feels. I could be overly suspicious from my early impression of her when she was insisting on being some master manipulator.

    I didn’t mention this in post but I do swing back and forth between suspicion and annoyance, and a feeling of being disrespected by her behaviour – to the opposite, that she’s just a sweet and caring friend who has a strong and long lasting friendship with Sam, accompanied by a feeling of shame and regret for thinking such things. Of course both sides of the pendulum make me feel AWFUL.

    I’ve never mentioned any disapproval of them working together, as I am happy for Sam to work with a close friend he is comfortable around, rather than an unpredictable new person. I still think it was a weird thing for her to say if it had no motive… maybe she was just blurting out random thoughts, or trying to tease Sam and make him feel insecure as a joke..? It still feels bizarre, when I’ve never mentioned moving out, but maybe you’re right in your second post, and everyone can tell I’m unhappy about being here without me mentioning it.

    Thank you for your suggestion that Jane would have mentioned by now if they had been together, I think you’re right, and it gave me some solace and a new perspective.

    From your second post and your questions;

    1) When we are alone, Sam is lovely, caring, affectionate and I feel great, I’m not worried about Jane unless she calls suddenly, or when he suddenly tells me we have plans with her without any warning or being asked.

    2) Yes, it’s true, it is a symptom of how I was raised, and most of my experiences in relationships and friendships before now, that I was shut down, ignored, or rejected, or in the worst cases my experience denied and rewritten when I brought up my feelings. I am still learning how to share my thoughts honestly, but I am scared of being too much, oversharing, or being too emotional to the point of spreading my depression and sense of being overwhelmed to others, and overwhelming them.

    3) Yes, I think so. I’m becoming less social, as people have recently noted that I look sad. since the beginning of our relationship, Sam and I had plans to travel at this time, and weren’t supposed to be living here, but life has played out like this and here we are, so I’m undoubtedly dissatisfied , as I should have been travelling Europe right now, not running out my savings . We are working on making new plans, but in the meantime, I think its obvious I’m unhappy.

    4) Yes, I used to live independently in the city, thats where we met, and we were a long distance couple for the first 9 months. The longest we spent apart is 2 weeks on 2 occasions, one of us would visit the other every week or so. we were supposed to go travelling when I ran out my lease, but Sam hasn’t saved as much as I have, and wants to stay and make more money. I worked 3 jobs to get some extra income and save up, but I guess he didn’t really make the same effort early on. He has said he’s a bit scared, so I’m trying to convince him we should just go be adventurous, but without pressuring him too much. I left behind my independence, and my belongings are all in storage, as we were intending to be gone.

    I am becoming a little conflicted, as I’m comfortable travelling solo, and desperately want to go, so part of me is beginning to say, just leave, just go without him. but I love my boyfriend and he loves me, and I’m worried our relationship won’t last if I leave him behind.

    I have some good friends and support in the city, but I my commitment to travel and be together with Sam had me excited to leave. I suppose I feel let down. like I’m not a priority anymore, and our plans were not as serious to him as they were to me.

    I just feel sad. Perhaps my issues and spiralling thoughts are just my own brain taking all these observations and trying to inflate them to place blame or find reasons to be upset, because I feel guilty getting upset at Sam directly.. I don’t really know, it’s so confusing.

    Part of me says none of this should be happening, tiresome job hunting, getting upset, its a waste of my time, and I should just go discover England and France alone, but I love my boyfriend so much and he insists he does want the same things and has asked me to wait, so I’m torn between my life long ambitions and my newer commitment to my partner.

    #461798
    anita
    Participant

    Good Sat afternoon (for both of us, being 3 hours apart), Olive 🙂

    I just spent a few hours reading through your recent posts and I’m not even close to being done with processing all that you shared in this thread.

    I am experiencing your level of self-reflection, emotional honesty and willingness to look at the role of your own past emotional wounds as the cause of your disatisfaction (rather than projecting full blame unto others) as exceptional and extraordinary, admirable, really. My hat is off to you!

    I need more time to process, and would like to get back to you this evening. But for now (and please let me know what you think of my current understanding at any time and correct me where I may be wrong):

    Both of you, living in the city, decided to go on an adventure travel to Europe. You worked 3 jobs in the city, saved as much money for the trip, placed your belongings in storage, and moved with him temporarily to the small town of his youth because he didn’t save enough money in the city and wanted to work and save more money working in his small town.

    You moved there with him but the focus seemed to have shifted from the two of you saving for a trip to Europe => to him re-living his adolescense and Jane is a big part of it.

    It’s as if suddenly he’s not only 3 years younger than you (27/30), but 13 years younger, a 17 year-old teenager having fun with his teenage friend (Jane).

    From what you shared, it doesn’t seem to me that Sam and Jane are having a romantic adult relationship, seems more like a re-enactment of a teenage relationship where physical and even sexual elements may be part of simply because of immaturity and a lack of adult discernment.

    So, now.. having emotionally a 17-year-old boyfriend, you are in a strange position.. ?

    🤔 Anita

    #461800
    Alessa
    Participant

    Hi Olive

    Well it’s good she’s leaving in a few weeks. I don’t think you’re wrong for feeling the way you do. Now you have to find a way through it. 🩵

    Good luck talking to Sam about things! Keeping things simple and less emotional are techniques that help make conversations less stressful.

    Is it difficult living with his family?

    It sucks that things didn’t work out as you hoped and that you’re in a very awkward place at the moment. Hopefully you get a job soon, can save up a bit of money and go travelling! Just hang in there, and you might feel a bit happier when she moves away. 🙏

    #461808
    anita
    Participant

    Hey Olive 🙂

    The original plan was that you and Sam would travel together to Europe. You structured your life around that goal:

    You left your independent city life, placed your belongings in storage, worked multiple jobs and saved money. Then the plan stalled because Sam got nervous and wanted to save more money.

    You made concrete sacrifices. Now, you are unemployed, living with his parents, using up your savings, and watching time pass while the dream that motivated your sacrifices remains uncertain.

    You wanted movement, adventure, Europe and a future with Sam while he seems to be currently attached to the familarity of his old, teenage/early 20s life. His old life seems to be his priority, not his new life with you.

    I think that what you need most at this time is clarity: clarity about the future travel plans, about Sam’s actual timelines, and whether his priorities and yours still align.

    The behaviors between Jane and Sam would disturb, I’m guessing, 90-95% of girlfriends in your place, even though, seems to me, the behaviors you’re aware of are all that there is between them. Still, it’d be unpleasant, to say the least, for almost every girlfriend.

    I have more thoughts, but please tell me what you think/ feel about what I wrote so far..?

    🤔 Anita

    #461824
    Roberta
    Participant

    Hi Olive
    What is it that you wanted to experience by travelling? famous sights different culture, museums/art galleries, the landscape?
    Do you & Sam want to see & do the same things when travelling? Was the goal of travelling the glue that kept you two together?
    Are you mentally saying to yourself ” I will be happy when……” Some people work their socks off all year just to have a two week foreign holiday, whereas others can happily find something special & uplifting in their own neighboring area week in week out.
    I hope that life brings you the love & adventure you are looking for.
    Roberta

    #461858
    anita
    Participant

    How are you, Olive?

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 18 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.