Home→Forums→Relationships→Should we Separate?!?
- This topic has 64 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 1 week, 6 days ago by
anita.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 25, 2025 at 10:13 am #452212
anitaParticipantDear Dave:
“It just felt to me that nothing I was doing was quite good enough – it was champagne or razorblades and not much in between… the highs were so high that I felt like a drug addict chasing the next high and forgetting about the tough parts in between… shed always say “I really want to be led and someone to share the responsibility with me” the more I did this the more it felt like it still wasn’t good enough or at her level. A bit of a vicious circle…”-
Back on Nov 6 (on this page), I talked about two concepts that explain this dynamic: Intermittent Reinforcement and Trauma Bonding. You can research these two terms, if you’d like.
Intermittent reinforcement, unlike consistent reinforcement, is what keep people addicted to using slot machines, for example. You don’t get a reward every time, you get it occasionally and unpredictably. When you do, dopamine surges (a “high”), and you keep playing for the next “high”. In abusive or toxic relationships, one partner positively rewards the other occasionally, unpredictably and that creates a “high” that keeps the partner hooked.
In a relationship like yours, when one partner is repeatedly cold/ disapproving/ critical and then- occasionally, unpredictably- rewards you with spending the night together, or telling you she still loves you- it’s the unpredictability of the positive reward that feels like an intense “high” and reinforces the emotional attachment/ bonding on the part of the victim of this dynamic.
From a source online: “Trauma bonding is a strong emotional attachment formed between a victim and an abuser, often through cycles of abuse and intermittent kindness. The unpredictability of affection or approval creates a powerful dependency. Victims often feel that if they just ‘try harder,’ they’ll get the reward (love, safety, validation) again. The victim may confuse abuse with love, rationalize harmful behavior, or feel unable to leave. Intermittent reinforcement is the psychological engine behind trauma bonding.”
Back to your words, Dave: “Not to be rude, but since when did she get to decide what the level should be and if I am or not good enough. The only person who should be able to dictate this is me… I have moved quite a bit of my stuff back into my old house and I have a renewed sense of hope and an overwhelming feeling of ‘I’ve got this!’ as I embark on this new journey. So much more equipped for what is needed and who I am meant to be moving forward. All in all the only person who can dictate if I am good enough is me!”-
Excellent thinking, Dave 🤞 My advice: beware of the addiction factor and the possibility, maybe likelihood of the next positive reward that may feel like.. the best thing in the world. On her part, she may be hooked on feeling superior to you and on keeping you hooked.. If she loses your interest completely, who would she feel superior in relation to?
Let’s say she does lose your romantic interest completely.. it’s not unthinkable that her next partner will also be.. not good-enough.
May the force be with you (a Star Wars saying 😊),Dave.
🤍 Anita
January 21, 2026 at 5:57 pm #454404
anitaParticipantHow are you, Dave???
February 3, 2026 at 3:33 am #454890
DaveParticipantHi Anita,
I am doing really well thankyou and I really appreciate you following up with me.
I have now formally filed for divorce from my ex, and while this process will understandably take some time, filing itself brought up very mixed emotions. On one hand, there is regret that the person I once envisioned spending my life with and I have come to this point. On the other, there is a genuine sense of excitement and optimism for the next chapter of my life.
Thankfully, the divorce process should be relatively straightforward. We are aligned on childcare arrangements and already own our homes separately. Neither of us has any desire to make this process difficult, prolonged, or contentious. She has assured me that she will not be seeking anything from me, and I feel the same toward her.
We ended our relationship conversations with what I believe was grace and mutual respect. I told her that I want her to be happy, and that regardless of everything, I believe we will remain close — not only because of our children, but because at our core we have always been friends. I genuinely want her to succeed and find happiness, even if that future is not with me. Her response reflected the same maturity and care: “Somehow along the way we have stopped making each other happy. Nothing major has happened, but I want you to be happy, and I’m truly sorry that being together has made us both feel less somehow. My love for you won’t waver, but sometimes love alone isn’t enough to make it work.”
More recently, after a chance meeting while walking my dog shortly after Christmas, I connected with someone new. We have been casually dating, and she is genuinely lovely. I like her a lot. She lives nearby and has been very respectful of my situation and the fact that I am still going through a divorce and that things naturally take time. The early signs are very positive — she makes me feel excited, and the connection is steadily growing.
Most importantly, my children are happy, and I am grateful that I get to see them as often as possible. Our co-parenting arrangement works well: while we have a fixed schedule, we remain flexible and supportive of one another as plans change. She has also shared that she has met someone she is getting to know. While it is still early, being open about moving on has reinforced for both of us that separating was the right decision. We are able to talk honestly, without fear of manipulation or resentment — something I’m told is rare, but I’m thankful for.
Finally, having separated previously and then choosing to try again makes me feel genuinely proud of us. We both showed up, made the effort, and never once gave up on each other. As we move forward, my intention is to remain calm, respectful, and supportive where possible, as long as that mutual respect and understanding continues.
February 3, 2026 at 4:43 am #454892
RobertaParticipantDear Dave
Congratulations to you & your soon to be ex wife, so many people could learn so much from the pair of you on how to review, try again & amicable admit that a parting of the ways is the right thing for both of you. I am glad that both of you have found love in another direction & that you actively co parent which teaches your children the together apart way of being a family.
Best wishes
RobertaFebruary 3, 2026 at 9:47 am #454899
anitaParticipantDear Dave:
Reading your update makes my day 🙏 🙂
Your message is rich with emotional clarity and grounded maturity — it’s rare (and my first time witnessing it) to see someone navigate a difficult transition with this much respect, steadiness, and genuine care for everyone involved.
The way you and your ex are co‑parenting, communicating, and choosing grace over conflict says a lot about your values. And it’s lovely to read that you’re feeling hopeful again and connecting with someone new who brings light into your life.
I’m really glad to hear you’re in a good place and moving forward with so much intention 🤍✨🙏 🌿
Whenever you feel like sharing more — the good, the messy, or anything in between — I’m here.
🤍 Anita
-
AuthorPosts
Though I run this site, it is not mine. It's ours. It's not about me. It's about us. Your stories and your wisdom are just as meaningful as mine.